Name: The Elite
Rating: 3.54 (89 reviews)

Really fast read which was nice.

I really couldn't stand America, though. Her emotions are so fickle and irrational. Two pages after Maxon says he wants to choose her she's wondering if he's going to send her home. She doesn't listen to him at all or have an actual conversation when she needs to. He's totally right when he says that she's rash and blames everyone, especially him, for everything she thinks is wrong with the world. She spent the first book being really honest and doesn't talk to him about anything in this one.. Her internal monologue with not nearly enough dialog also is a whole lot of telling. I almost stopped reading it but I was 261 pages in (seriously, fast read) and I was curious how it would end.

I did like the ending, finally. And of course I'm going to read the third one because I've already gotten this far.

But I find myself wishing Kiera Cass had taken notes from the pilot of The Selection. She's set up this wider world with Northern rebels and Southern rebels and what they all want. But she spends the whole book inside the palace with a very small cast. The biggest conflicts arecat fights between the girls or America's wavering anger/jealousy/love for Maxon when there's obviously so much else going on. It could involve a lot more intrigue and tie in political conflict and suspense more than it does. The pilot was flawed but it expanded the world well and offered more interesting conflict.

Having read the third book, I'd maybe up this to 2.5 stars because there's one or two moments that weren't so bad.

"I should have proposed that night in your room."
"I should have let you."

BookNook — Young Adult book reviews

I feel like an author. With writer's block. I'm sitting here, staring at a blank page, and I have no idea how to form my words. The Elite was everything I hoped it would be: it was intense, romantic, emotional, but it was also conflicting. There were a few things I was very unsure about and my emotions were pulled all over the place. But even so, I loved this book!

The Selection itself is an odd thing, because it's so weird, and so... disgusting. It is so completely un-romantic. In The Elite, Maxon dates six girls, he whispers sweet things into their ears, and he kisses a handful of them... all at once (not literally, like some giant orgy, but you know what I mean). There were some very specific moments in The Elite where this really threw me for a loop. One example: Maxon is leaving for a while and all the girls are lined up to bid him farewell. He literally goes down the line of girls, kissing them on the cheek/hand/whatever and whispering sweet goodbyes to each one personally. It was literally like Maxon was a man with six wives, and that was pretty gross. If I were America, I would feel like my boyfriend was cheating on me five times, right in front of me.

As someone who doesn't take cheating or jealousy well, that whole idea sits ill with me. But despite all my reservations and aggravation towards this fact, I cannot help but adore this series. It's like a drug. Something about the competition draws me in. Who will win?? But that being said, there were times that I just wanted to bash Maxon's face in. He claims that America is the one for him, but then why does he have to continue being sweet with the other girls?? I almost felt like it was happening to me, because the anger and jealousy were so strong. At one point he does try to explain and justify why he was running around making out with the royal bitch herself—Celeste—but I wasn't buying it. His excuse was basically, "You haven't made up your mind, the other girls are holding out on me, and I'm horny." Bleh.

I started out this book as a 100% Maxon fan. I hated Aspen's guts for his reason for breaking up with America. It's so annoying and so selfish (despite the attempt to actually be selfless). But The Elite rocked my emotions in so many different ways, that now I'm not even sure whose side I'm on. If it weren't for the whole "multiple girls" thing, I would still be Team Maxon. But seeing him with other girls has made me doubt. Even though I have sworn to hate Aspen for all eternity, at least he's a one-girl man. Maxon is sweet and all, but it was so hard for me to stay completely devoted to him. I feel myself wavering!

I personally still love America, but I can understand how she's not for everyone. America cries a lot in The Elite and she's not always portrayed as the strongest character. It didn't bother me much, but I know some people really don't like girls who cry a lot. I think I can sympathize with her though. I see the amount of stress she's under, and I just want to hug her. I can totally understand the love triangle because, in this book, I felt it too. I'm so confused about which guy I love more, so I completely get why America was confused and stressed and unsure, and thus breaking down into tears and hysterics. I got it!

One of the things I loved most about The Elite was how we learn a lot more about how the country was founded. The world building isn't a huge part of the story, but it was a nice side plot to all the girl drama. The tid-bits we do learn are pretty morbidly interesting (does that even make sense? Probably not, until you read the book). But the facts we learn start to play a big role in forming America's political opinions and ideals. I imagine, and I hope, that they will also play a huge role in the third book!

I am so insanely grateful for this book. It was EXACTLY what I needed, because I was getting ready to commit reading suicide due to reading so many "meh" books. But with The Elite, I was ripping through the pages and giggling like an insane person. There were times when I even spoke to the book. Yes, you heard correctly. MY NAME IS ASHLEY AND I SPOKE TO THE BOOK! You know when a narrator/MC sometimes asks rhetorical questions? I answered them. Out loud. Example:

America (to herself): "Can I win this competition?"
Me: "YES, GIRL!! YOU TOTALLY CAN!£!@"@"e£"j"""$3242141"

I may need to be committed.

Also, I was just like America. I was crying over everything. Happy, sad, you name it. There were tears involved.

Sweet letter from father? Tears—check.
Maxon making sweet promises? Tears—check.
Heartfelt moment between America and her maids? Tears—check.
Another letter from her father? Tears—check.
Sad moment with one of The Elite girls? Tears—check.

Yes, I had reservations with this book. I love Maxon to bits, but there were still times when I hated him. The whole idea of The Selection is kind of "what the hell". But this is one of those books that I just love with every fiber of my being. I adore it. I love it. It's my drug. This book, along with The Selection invokes my strongest emotions. It makes me cry, it makes me laugh, it makes me want to read more, more, more, MORE! I gobble up every word, every kiss, every hysterical meltdown. I am confident that fans of The Selection will enjoy this book just as much as I did! It will not disappoint, and I must say, I'm super curious to hear about everyone's thoughts towards Maxon!

I don't even want to know what the release date is for book 3, because I'm sure it will be depressingly far away.

*FanGirlScream*

Kelly

Written on Jun 24, 2013

The Elite is the continuation of The Selection, with the storyline focusing on the competition between the girls and America's lingering decision on whether to commit to the potential life as a princess, or the wife of a guardsmen. America has lost her nerve and flitting between the two boys, she has lost her sense of identity. Where Maxon was the unlikely and surprising front runner in The Selection, neither Maxon or Aspen are worthy in The Elite, nor does America deserve either one.

As far as the rebels are concerned, I was hoping that we would be introduced to their cause and how they are involved within the series... But nothing evolved beyond storming the castle. They seem as though they are merely scenery in a twisted love story of sorts. I still can't class the series as dystopian, rather not much more than romance. I'll be interested to read the synopsis for the third book in the series. I suspect it'll be little more than Maxon choosing a bride, and America stringing along both boys. Here's hoping I'm wrong.

sstaley

Written on Jun 23, 2013

I loved this 2nd book just as much as the first, if not better. I felt the characters were more defined and the relationships deeper. I can't wait for the 3rd book and my teen daughter feels the same!

mrs_mander_reads

Written on May 24, 2013

From start to finish, this book completely infuriated me. It's definitely not that I didn't like it... I would almost complete it to middle school - a completely terrible time in my life on my way to something great. Uncomfortable, but necessary. The book was well written, and the story keeps me involved. I'm waiting anxiously for the conclusion.

The Elite (The Selection, #2)

by Kiera Cass

Amy Rubinate (Narrator)

The Elite (The Selection, #2)

by Kiera Cass

Amy Rubinate (Narrator)

Reviews

Kelly

sstaley

mrs_mander_reads

ladygrey

Annie Jackson

Ashley