Good Witch Hunting (Witchless in Seattle, #7)

by Dakota Cassidy

Hollie Jackson (Narrator)

• ISBN10: 1977368255
• ISBN13: 9781977368256
• Publish Date: 26 June 2018
• Publish Status: Out of Print
• Out of Print: 16 March 2021
• Publish Country: US
• Imprint: Tantor Media, Inc
• Edition: Unabridged edition
• Format: Audiobook (MP3)
• Duration: 5 hours and 57 minutes
• Language: English

Reviews

[Kim Deister]

I love the smart humor and quirky characters of this series! This one is probably my favorite thus far, with the addition of Trixie and Coop. The pacing was on point, and the mystery was fun to read, even if it was solved a little differently than is usual in this series.

My only real complaint is the neverending “romance” complications between Stevie and Win. The primary complication being that Stevie lives on the plane of the living, and Win, as a ghost, does not. Not something that is conducive to a relationship. In the last novel, several times, Win touches on the subject, lamenting that he can’t fully disclose his feelings for her until he finds a way back to her plane, not wanting to put her life on hold while she waits for something that might not ever happen. Fair. However, the one attempt at romance Stevie has had was dismissed early on in the series, leaving her open for a potential relationship with Win. Now, in this book, she’s dealing with jealously regarding Win’s former earthly romance, and those he “must” be pursuing on the other plane. It feels to me as if this star-crossed lover situation had long since been established, Yet in this book, there’s a lot of the “does he/she like me” vibe to it. That felt weird, as it seemed they’d largely gotten then under control and created a stronger dynamic between them in earlier books.

[Berls]

I've been plowing through this series so quickly and been very negligent about writing reviews.... so needless to say this is coming a full week or so after finishing the book :/

What I liked:
- Sometimes I almost forget this series is a paranormal cozy series because the paranormal elements are so light. But this one really brought them to the forefront in a fun way.
- the characters continue to be a favorite element and I only wish some of them were going to be sticking around long term
- the narration continues to be really good and I will definitely be listening to future books

What could have been better:
- she doesn't actually solve the mystery, which she acknowledges too. She just kinda falls into it and trouble (as usual) and I just would have liked to see more detective work

[kimbacaffeinate]

A nun, a demon and a ghost walk into a bar...

In Good Witch Hunting a demon is accused of murder and it's a good thing, well at least for Stevie who has been quite bored since she investigated her last case.  This was a fun episode with plenty of twists and good humor. I enjoyed meeting Coop, Trixie, and a familiar named Livingston. Things are complicated by a snowstorm in Ebenezer Falls but that doesn't stop this motley crew.

The story behind Coop and Trixie was a fascinating one and could easily have been its own book. I think from a series perspective this was one of the best books to date. The pacing, humor and storyline quickly pulled me in and I devoured the audiobook. I loved the witty humor, snark and references to old sitcoms.

Hollie Jackson continues her narration and does a stellar job giving each character their own unique voice and captures their personality. Her voice for Belfrey, Stevie's familiar made me insane for a little while. Now I don't know whether she toned the voice down or I've simply accepted it, but Belfrey and I got along just fine this listen. This review was originally posted at Caffeinated Reviewer

[EBookObsessed]

I was so happy to see another Witchless in Seattle story had come out and that is why it is so much worse when the story was disappointing.

Stevie, our favorite powerless witch and spirit-hearing madam, is awakened by her awesome spy-guy Crispin Alistair Winterbottom, or Win for short, when he suddenly has a revelation that the person who murdered him had a very distinct tattoo. Good thing a new tattoo artist just moved into town and is setting up shop down the street from Stevie’s Madam Zoltar 2.0.

Stevie goes to visit and introduce herself to her new neighbors and surprise, surprise, they find a dead body in the storage room and no one knows how he got there. Yes, it is a murder mystery series but it was just too…convenient.

The new neighbors might have been more interesting if they were more of a mystery but the story description already tells us that one is an ex-nun and the other is a demon. They also have a pet owl/demon who spoke with an Irish accent, just to mix it up a bit. It would have added something to the story if we were unaware of Coop being a demon. She is supermodel gorgeous and talks a bit awkwardly like English isn’t her first language and she is unused to American slang. If we had to wonder and guess why she acted so strangely, that would have added to this storyline and the interest. And just as these new characters were getting interesting, we find that the new neighbors, Coop and Trixie and their owl buddy, won’t be sticking around town after this story.

I had several issues with this story starting with the fact that the entire thing happened during a blizzard where Stevie kept going out to get clues driving between her house and town, which is normally a 10 minute drive and now was taking over an hour. Hint, might not be a good idea to go out driving in a blizzard and who did she think was going to be out and about besides her.

She also didn’t figure out this mystery. It was more like she kept falling into the killer’s path and getting knocked around. Until in the end she finally got in the killer’s way and got a confession to buy some time in hopes that someone would come out in the blizzard and save her.

Most annoyingly was what is happening with the romance between Stevie and Win. Yes, she is a witch and he is a ghost and that makes dating harder. But in the last novel, which was from Win’s point of view, several times we hear Win’s unfinished thoughts that he can’t tell Stevie of his feelings for her since he hasn’t figured out how to return to the living world full-time (he has possessed a few bodies for the short-time) and it is not fair to make her wait. Yet the romance Stevie had in the first few stories with the local coffeehouse owner was quickly nixed so that we could focus on Win and Stevie. In this novel, Stevie is obsessed with her jealousy of Win’s former fiance, how Win must be spending time on plane-limbo with other women while she sleeps and how he will never return her affection.

I had thought that we long ago established their star-crossed lover romance and hashed out their strong feelings for each other. Really, why else is he trying to get back to this plane of existence? Just to use that wood fire pizza oven?

This is book 7 in the series and we are far enough along that we shouldn’t still be dragging in teenage-agnst of “does he like me like I like him?” They had a stronger relationship and understanding of the other’s feeling in the earlier stories.

In the last story, I was disappointed that Win didn’t give us more about how he plans on returning to the living but this one flopped on so many levels and I am truly disappointed. Tell me, can a book series “jump the shark?”

See more at EBookObsessed.com