Sylvester or the Wicked Uncle

by Georgette Heyer

• ISBN10: 0848806956
• ISBN13: 9780848806958
• Publish Date: 6 June 1957
• Publish Status: Active
• Publish Country: US
• Imprint: Amereon Ltd
• Format: Hardcover
• Language: English

Reviews

[jamiereadthis]

Perhaps the best botched proposal since Darcy. And no offense to Lady Catherine de Bourgh (actually, yes, offense to Lady Catherine de Bourgh), I so much prefer the mighty Lady Salford. Tenderness, mischief, and sense of humor. I want to write a book just to fill it with those three things. Except I guess that would be redundant, since Heyer has already done so.

Fifth star just for the audio, because Nicholas Rowe rendered each character so fantastically that he had me belly-laughing right up to the end.

“I collect, from all I have heard, that she is unusual.”

“Oh, yes, she’s unusual,” he said bitterly. “She blurts out whatever may come into her head. She tumbles from one outrageous escapade into another. She’s happier grooming horses and hobnobbing with stable hands than going to parties. She’s impertinent. You daren’t catch her eye for fear she should start to giggle. She hasn’t any accomplishments. I never saw anyone with less dignity. She’s abominable, and damnably hot at hand, frank to a fault, and— a darling!”

[Stephanie]

Originally posted at Once Upon a Chapter

Really a 4.5.

Sylvester has had a charmed life. He is a duke and has held his position well from a young age. He pays his staff well and none of his tenants have complaints. He has seen to everyone’s welfare. Sylvester doesn’t let anyone past his walls though. He is polite and fulfills his role as duke as he should. Nothing more, nothing less. He even approaches marriage as nothing more than choosing the right girl to fulfill the position of duchess. He has chosen five eligible girls who would fill the role but finds them all with one fault or another. He seeks his mother’s advice as he wants to make sure his future bride and mother will become friends. Sylvester’s mother is distressed to learn about her son’s arrogance but tells him instead that he was once engaged to a her dear friend’s daughter. Sylvester had been 8 and Phoebe just 3 days old.

Phoebe Marlow is a young woman who has lived under her step-mother’s thumb from a very young age. Lady Marlow is very strict and demands her house follow the rules that she finds proper. Anyone not in compliance finds themselves at the end of Lady Marlow’s very sharp tongue. Phoebe escapes by talking with the governess and writing fiction. When she learns the Duke of Salford means to come to Austerby to offer for her she flies into a panic. Phoebe’s first book has been accepted and is to be published in the very near future. Not only does Phoebe not have any emotional ties to Sylvester but he is the basis of her novel’s villain! Phoebe has no clue that with a few exceptions her novel is dangerously close to the truth.

Sylvester and Phoebe’s relationship is a whirlwind! Their adventure includes no less than being stranded at an end, a big misunderstanding, kidnapping and across seas adventures! It isn’t as overwhelming as it seems though. Heyer does a wonderful job with Sylvester or the Wicked Uncle. I watched Sylvester go from this man who didn’t see anything wrong with himself and how he conducted himself to this man who realizes that he isn’t complete without love.

The secondary characters do not overwhelm the story but rather add to it. Ianthe, Sylvester’s widowed sister-in-law, was drawn particularly well. I’ve never wanted to punch a character more when she was on the scene. Tom is Phoebe’s only friend and he stands by her with steadfastness. If it hadn’t been for their more sibling like relationship, Tom would have suited Phoebe wonderfully. He was such a sweetie. I think that my favorite secondary character was Edmund, Sylvester’s nephew. He won me over the instant he told a particularly awful character that “his uncle Vester would grind his bones for bread!”

This really would have been a five star book if not for two things. Phoebe drove me nuts at times. The girl was unbelievably stubborn and I wanted to shake her on more than one occasion. She did drag the story down for me a bit. The second was the ending. I don’t like the endings in books to be rushed or to abruptly end. This book did both. One minute it looked like impending disaster and after a very brief conversation bam we hit the ending. There wasn’t much description after the happy couple finally became the happy couple. I’m nosey. I’ll admit it freely, especially when it comes to characters that I care about. It would have been nice to have more details or a nice epilogue. It left me wanting more.

Sylvester is a great historical romance and it really shouldn’t be missed! This was my first Georgette Heyer novel and I look forward to reading her back list!