readingwithwrin
Written on May 5, 2017
But all she heard was the roaring in her ears, the rasping of her own breath.”
This is my second book by Breslin and I am so disappointed that she would go with a nazi romance. I feel like this story could have gone so many other ways, and would have been so much more enjoyable without the romance. I just didn't like it at all, and it made me uncomfortable, and not a good kind of uncomfortable or one that I'm just uncomfortable because I don't understand it, but one that made me feel sick to my stomach with how wrong it was.
Your probably wondering if it made me feel sick to my stomach, how can I still give it three star rating? Well that's because of Hadassah aka Stella our main character. Even though she was terrified of the Nazi commandant and was very confused with why he had taken her from the concentration camp to his home, she still put up a good front and was extremely brave. She questioned him at every opportunity at first and even took risks that would end her own life if anyone found out to save a few people in the camps.
We also have kind and caring Joseph a Jewish child who has been treated awful in the camps until the commandant saw him and then had him working in the house to protect him.
Then we have Helen who is the cook and isn't able to speak and we learn her story, and we see how protective she is of Joseph as well. It was just nice to see some good parts in this story.
This was similar to the Queen Esther story in the bible and it is a modern day re-telling of it in a way.
So your probably thinking that since its a Queen Esther story that the commandant is going to turn out to be good, and save everyone. Wrong, yes he does save some people at the risk of his own life, but he let so many others die for so long even though he knew it was wrong. He only started helping protect people once Hadassah was bring it to his attention and saying hey this isn't okay.
Overall was a disappointing read with a few bright spots that made me not completely hate it.
Blog Twitter Instagram Facebook