Leah
Written on Jun 20, 2010
It doesn’t take long for Ginny and Adam to get caught up in the whirlwind that is the Sale’s life and when the youngest Sale, Pippi, brings a new friend into the fray, Zach, everyone finds themselves not knowing where they’re at and suddenly all kinds of secrets are spilling out. The trouble with telling secrets though is that, inevitably, new secrets end up being made. But what is it about Zach that makes everyone fall under his charm and loosen their tongues?
I have to admit that when I first picked up a book by Louise Candlish I wasn’t sure what to expect. In fact, I only picked it up because I needed to make up the books I was swapping. I didn’t expect to read Since I Don’t Have You but I didn’t know what else to read so I gave it a go. It turns out, that was probably one of the best buys I made as I absolutely loved the book and it’s one of my favourites. Since then I’ve eagerly bought up some of Louise’s other books and although I wasn’t a fan of her last book Before We Say Goodbye, I was still thrilled to receive her latest book Other People’s Secrets to review.
It’s fair to say that since her first book, Prickly Heat, Louise has gone from writing chick lit books to writing women’s fiction books. Her books no longer seem to revolve around the usual you find in chick lit books. There are no single twenty-somethings looking to find Mr Right (although since I haven’t read her debut, I can’t tell you if that’s what it’s about, but you get my point). Her books don’t have a love story, not the type you find in chick lit anyway and her books now seem to have a more serious tone. Because of the way her books are written, the pace isn’t as fast as I’m used to and I have to admit, it does take a while to get used to.
So with the slow pace in mind, there isn’t actually a lot that happens in Other People’s Secrets. Not really. Yes, as the title suggest, there are a lot of secrets floating around, but the main crux of the story centers on the Sale family, Ginny and Adam Trustlove and mysterious arrival of Zach. All of this takes place on the picturesque Lake Orta in Italy. The setting of the events for each of the characters is perfect. Because they’re all struggling with personal problems and tragedies and are trying to work out where they stand in life, the beautiful Lake Orta is a rather stunning backdrop. It sounds like such a wonderful place to go for a peaceful holiday and I could easily imagine the house within which the Sale family stayed, as well as the little boathouse where Ginny and Adam were staying. I’ve Googled some pictures and I would love to visit there one day as it sounds so lovely.
It’s hard for me to really say which characters I liked or disliked because with so many characters and so many different problems running throughout it’s hard to know what they’re really like. Because the book is only set around the holiday in Italy, Ginny and Adam spend the majority of their time being, understandably, sad. The tragedy they suffered really comes off the pages and I’ve never read a book with such characters suffering such horrible things. I will readily admit that it was mildly depressing, to see two characters trying to pull themselves together without completely falling apart was a bit hard to read because their grief seems so real. I found it hard to really get a handle on Ginny but she definitely evoked sympathy in me. Adam seemed to be coping a bit better and he didn’t seem like a nice character. The way he tried to help Ginny was admirable because although he was suffering, too, he knew he needed to help his wife also. The Sale’s on the other hand were a bit of an enigma, but they had a bit more of a sparkle. I really liked Bea Sale, the head of the family. She seemed like such a nice character. I wasn’t a huge fan of Marty, Bea’s husband. As for Bea and Marty’s children, the only one we really get to know is Pippi who was definitely the life and soul of the book. The final character pivotal to the story is Zach, the most mysterious of all. I had a few inklings about him, but nothing solid and I was a bit shocked by what we learn about him, however I did like him. He was probably my favourite character.
Louise is a fantastic writer, there’s absolutely no doubt about that. Most of the secrets that do come out are surprising. I kept trying to guess just what it was Dom was keeping hidden and I was stunned by what it was because I didn’t see it coming at all. I think the problem I had with the book was the pace. Which isn’t Louise’s problem at all, but I’m used to faster paced books and I did at times just want everyone to just spill the beans.The book is definitely aimed at the older market and I’m sure that Louise’s books are similar to Joanna Trollope’s books although I’ve never read any of Joanna’s books. I don’t like to place an age-range for books because, after all, any age (within reason) can read about people of any age and I’ve read many books with female characters older than me, but Other People’s Secrets did seem incredibly grown up and it was definitely out of my comfort zone and I’m not altogether sure it was my kind of book. I’m sure loads of people will love the book because it is well written, and I did stick with it throughout, but I don’t think it’s geared towards myself and that’s not Louise’s problem, not at all, but it did make it a difficult read for me.