Reviewed by llamareads on

4 of 5 stars

Share
Just like the cover shows, this is a cute and humorous novella about two thirty-something urban planners finding love among NYC architecture.

“I think you might be the most driven person I know.” Then, thinking it sounded cold or off-putting somehow, he hastily added, “That’s a compliment, by the way.”


After her divorce, Fay has little time for anything other her work as a partner at an urban planning firm. So it’s just her luck that when she finally decides to get out and enjoy a house tour, she gets cornered by a creep and has to enlist the help of Oliver, an old friend, to pretend to be her boyfriend so the guy leaves her alone. Oliver and Fay reconnect, and as one thing leads to another, they end up on a series of dates revolving around historic architecture.

This is pretty short – only 113 pages – so there’s not much room for the relationship to really grow. A lot of it is built on remembered experiences from college rather than things than happen in the present day. The fake dating thing is a bit odd. They only pull that out for the initial meet-cute and then again when touring apartments they have no intention of buying, which felt a bit off to me (as well as the fact that they basically go for third-base during a house showing). The main conflict of the story revolves around the fact that Oliver has applied for a job at Fay’s firm, but Fay isn’t aware of it. At several points, Oliver considers discussing it with her, but he never brings it up for one reason or another. I didn’t like this part of the book at all – it verged too close on outright lying, one of my personal pet peeves – and Oliver knows exactly how badly Fay would take it if (when!) she finds out. There is the excuse that Fay refuses to talk about their jobs, as her ex was particularly defensive about talking about his and outright dismissive when she talked about hers. I loved that Fay was a very successful woman, though it was something that her ex deeply resented. I also loved how upfront she was with Oliver about exactly what she wanted in a relationship. After he lost his job when the firm he worked at folded, Oliver has been doing contract work and living with his brother. He feels like a failure, especially compared to Fay. I loved Oliver’s brother Nat, and he absolutely stole the scenes he was in.

Overall, while I had my quibbles with the main plot device, I liked the writing and the humor, and will probably pick up the next in the series.

I received this book for free from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

Last modified on

Reading updates

  • Started reading
  • 29 July, 2019: Finished reading
  • 29 July, 2019: Reviewed