Rites of Passage has me a bit torn. There were definitely pros and cons with this book.
Things I Liked
For the most part, I LOVED Sam as a character. That girl is tough as nails! She gets an insane amount of shit thrown at her at the Denmark Military Academy, but she never backs down. There were tons of times when I wish she'd stand up for herself more, but that's just not military style, so I understand why she didn't. If I were her, I probably would have punched everyone in the face 5 times instead of standing there and taking their shit.
The whole military aspect of this book was REALLY interesting. I'm so not a military person and I know very little about it. But reading about a hardcore military academy was pretty cool. This may seem weird, but Rites of Passage gave me the strongest urge to go to the gym. I read all about Sam running 5Ks, doing 5 million push ups, running through obstacle courses, etc. I wanted to jump up and get in on that! ...I'm sure I'll feel differently by tomorrow.
However, the shit the recruits got was insane. It was crazy to see how anti-women some of those guys were. What fucking century are we in? Sam beats half the guys in the training exercises, but the guys don't get shit for it—Sam does.. just because she's a girl. So even though she rocks, she's "not cut out for this". Whaaaa??
What I Didn't Like
This book was long—416 pages. But the thing is, I don't feel like it needed to be that long. There were a few times where the book felt slow. There was a ton of build up, but then nothing was happening, or there would be long periods where the plot felt like it was stalling. I think it could have been cut down.
I didn't hate the romance, but I feel like it wasn't developed well. At the beginning of the book, Sam actually has a half romance with a different guy.. this "half romance" went on for so long that I actually had to go and reread the synopsis, because I remembered it saying she falls for her drill sergeant, but this "half romance" was with someone else... It just had me confused. Then when the romance with the drill sergeant finally came into play in the second half, I LIKED it, but I feel like it never came off the ground. It wasn't the focus of the story so I guess it wasn't intended to be super heavy/detailed, but it still felt really awkwardly half developed (especially by the end).
And finally: the ending. Rites of Passage had A TON of build up. The hazing gets more and more violent and brutal.. then I feel like the end was really abrupt and not super satisfying. Without spoiling it, the ending was sort of like: the war isn't over, but we've won the battle.. but actually, even that's generous. It's more like: the war isn't over, but the bad guys don't feel like taking bad PR so they're letting us win this one battle. I was hoping for a lot more. Mostly, I wanted Karma to kick Matthews's ass but it didn't. The guy can still stay at the school! Also I wasn't pleased with Sam's brother's role. He was a total asshat to her the whole time, then at the end he was just like, "I couldn't let them know I was onto them. That's why I was an ass. I didn't mean it." Seriously? That's it?
Overall
I enjoyed a lot of Rites of Passage. It was interesting and felt different from other YA books just because of how military-heavy it was. Even other military books I've read have nothing on this one. Rites of Passage is more like: a day in the life of recruit. It's very cool! If only the romance and ending were a bit better, then thiss could have easily been a 4.5 star book!