Reviewed by shannonmiz on
But I actually started to like it after awhile! I had gotten a bit used to the world and the characters, and even though the text was gibberish, my eyes were starting to compute. I liked Nat and Wes, and really was started to get interested in what was happening to them. A good chunk of the book ended up taking place in a sea of frozen garbage... or something. Basically, Wes and his crew were being paid by Nat to take her to "the Blue" (which, incidentally, I feel like I have read before), and so it was a sea-trip of sorts, with all kinds of people trying to stop them on their illegal journey. That part was okay for awhile, I was even kind of getting into it, but then weird stuff that didn't make sense started happening. Someone ended up overboard, and everyone was like "okay, cool, see you never". And then all kinds of magical junk started showing up, and it made absolutely no sense, certainly not in the context of this book. I couldn't keep track of who had powers, who didn't, and (importantly to me) why. Then there were so many random groups of "bad guys", they were just showing up all over the place. I don't want to say too much of course, but suffice it to say that the ending was completely ridiculous, made zero sense, and basically made me just scream in frustration. I guess it was supposed to set up the next book but um, nope. It just confused me and made me angrier.
The world building... I needed more of it. Maybe some of these random powers and such would have worked if there was more of a context for them to work in. But as it stood, there were just so, so many unanswered questions for me that I couldn't get any visual of the setting. I was just getting "cold, dead stuff, ocean-like body of water, magic". And a kid eating his jacket, because that happened.
The other issue I had was that the characters felt like they could have worked. The bones were there, and maybe they'll be developed more in future books that I won't be reading, but they were kind of shells. I kept waiting for the character development to come, because it felt kind of close, but it never did. I feel like this book could have been a lot better had it been in first person dual POVs, but the third person dual POVs made me feel quite detached from both characters.
I guess the bottom line is that the whole book could have worked. The premise was pretty fantastic, and the characters had potential (hence the star and a half that I ended up giving it), but it never delivered, and then just got weird, complicated, confusing, and downright annoying.
1.5 Stars
*Copy provided for review via Netgalley
This review was originally posted on It Starts at Midnight
Reading updates
- Started reading
- 27 October, 2014: Finished reading
- 27 October, 2014: Reviewed