Item: Into The Blizzard
Rating: 1.00
Author: meowstina

by Michael Winter

“In June a few years ago I set out to visit some of the World War One battlefields of Europe – the slope and valley and river and plain that the Newfoundland Regiment trained on, and fought over and through and under.”

So begins Michael Winter’s extraordinary narrative that follows two parallel journeys, one laid on top of the other like a sketch on opaque paper over the lines of an old map. The first journey is that of the young men who came from Newfoundland’s outports, fields, villages and narrow city streets to join the storied regiment that led many of them to their deaths at Beaumont-Hamel during the Battle of the Somme on July 1, 1916. The second journey is the author’s, taken a century later as he walks in the footsteps of the dead men to discover what remains of their passage across land and through memory.

   Part unconventional history, part memoir-travelogue, part philosophical inquiry, Michael Winter uniquely captures the extraordinary lives and landscapes, both in Europe and at home, scarred by a war that is just now disappearing from living memory. In subtle and surprising ways, he also tells the hidden story of the very act of remembering – of how the past bleeds into the present and the present corrals and shapes the past. As he wanders from battlefield to barracks to hospital to hotel, and finally to a bereft stretch of land battered by a blizzard back home, Winter gently but persistently unsettles us – startling us with the unexpected encounters and juxtapositions that arise from his physical act of walking through the places where the soldiers once marched, this time armed with artifacts and knowledge those earlier souls could not have, yet undone by the reality of their bodily presence beneath the earth.

   In this unusual, poignant and beautiful book, Michael Winter gives us a new way of looking at a powerful piece of history that, he reminds us, continues to haunt our own lives.

I received an advanced reader copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

I tried. I tried so hard to be interested in and to like this book, but reading this book was so tedious. I really did want to learn more about Newfoundland’s history, especially before it became a part of Canada, because I think knowing our history is important. The fact that nonfiction tends to bore me is a factor in the way I feel about this book, but I think the format and writing also affected me.

This book is half history and half travelogue, which I wasn’t expecting, but it seemed like a cool concept. I was intrigued. From the beginning, though, I could see that it doesn’t work, at least for me. Winter tries to make connections between what he is doing and the past, and while those connections may be there, the way he presents them is quite stilted. A lot of this book, in this instance and for the book as a whole, feels disjointed and kind of random. It feels as if there is no clear path. While most of the history is told chronologically, Winter goes back and forth with describing battles and different soldiers and chunks of life back then. This made the book very hard to read and made me lose interest often.

Then again, maybe I just wasn’t into the book and that’s why it all seems disjointed. Since I wasn’t very interested it took me a while to read this book, and so I read snippets at a time. The concept seemed pretty interesting, but either my disinterest affected my reading or the execution just isn’t all that great.

Into The Blizzard

by Michael Winter

Reviewed by meowstina on Nov 7, 2014

Reading updates