Reviewed by Whitney @ First Impressions Reviews on
This book made me angry, I found there to be six victims in this story not three, and a vast miscarriage of justice. The West Memphis Three as they have been dubbed were guilty the minute they walked into the courtroom due to a biased jury and judge. Misskelley, who clearly has some learning disabilities was coerced into a false confession dragging Echols and Baldwin (unintentionally) down with him. After reading further on the case, past the 2002 publication of this book, see that there is no evidence that clearly points to these three boys and instead have seen suspicions and mismatched stories could have one believing that Terry Hobbs, Stevie Branch's step-father to be connected, although I should mention that this is just my opinion. This non-fiction novel was written nine years after their incarceration; in 2011 eighteen years after their conviction, The West Memphis Three were released under the Alfred Plea Deal.
I was disgusted while reading this book not only because of the heinous crimes themselves but also its aftermath, putting a foul taste in my mouth that lasted long after I turned the last page. Although, I think that is what made this book so readable, giving the reader a novel of just the facts, leaving them to decided the verdict.
Reading updates
- Started reading
- 5 September, 2012: Finished reading
- 5 September, 2012: Reviewed