Blue Window

by Adina Rishe Gewirtz

[Amber (The Literary Phoenix)]

Hmm.  Mixed feelings about this book.  On one hand, Blue Window was a really neat idea about five siblings who fall through a window and end up in a strange world where they have to find their way home and also not get destroyed by the strange looking humanoid inhabitants of that world.  It was a fun ride with nuances of The Chronicles of Narnia and A Wrinkle in Time.

On the other hand, this book was almost 600 pages long, and told the story in each of the childrens' POVs.  I actually love multiple POVs, but with this book, the formatting was odd.  I like multiple POVs when they switch comfortably between characters.  This means we would fall into the most interesting perspective.  Yes please!  In Blue Window, 1/5 of the book is told by each of the children, starting with the oldest and working to the youngest.  This was a bummer at times because by the time Max (for example) was doing interesting things, we've already left his perspective and oh well that ship has sailed.

I had a really hard time getting through this one.  Not because of the characters - they were good.  And the world building was good.  But, my goodness, the pacing was really, really slow.Gewirtz took great pains not to skip by the mundane parts like learning and traveling.  The problem with this is that all the real action happens in the last 60 pages because we've spent so long watching each child - one at a time - learn how to do the magic of this world.  After 480 pages of this, the ending felt very anti-climatic.  In some books, I like that vibe.  In Blue Window, I was bored.

Overall, it's an interesting book.  I think it would have been lovely as a more Narnia-esque drawn out story with fewer mundane scenes and several smaller novels.  This will appeal to folks who like sibling stories, magical worlds, and finding strength in yourself.  There's also a bit of a dystopia vibe, as this world has fallen to ruin.