This Christmas story was just perfect. It was the right length for the story, the characters were sweet and believable. The concept of the main characters having the same name in reverse and living one in the apartment above the other was a great idea. The only thing that might have been done differently would have been to have the story told just from Tyler's point of view, so we would only know what he knows to make the ending more of a surprise. But the way it was done works perfectly well.