Reviewed by girlinthepages on
This book has a ratio that's rare in YA contemporaries, with probably 75% of the relationships focusing on family and friends, and only 25% on romance. Layla and Sydney's friendship felt so tangible, from the awkward beginnings to Layla's family enveloping Sydney as one of their own. Layla and Sydney are such good friends to each other in small ways (like Layla sleeping with her air mattress pushed against Sydney's door...if you've read the book you'll know what I mean) and I found these small, quiet gestures of solidarity to be really refreshing and authentic. Their friendship isn't perfect, but it's real and true and developed, and I'd love to see more of that in YA.
Along with promoting strong female friendships, this book also delves into the joys and dysfunctions of family life, with the Stanfords and the Chathams juxtaposed in such an interesting way. Both families have had extreme hardships (and even scandals), but the way they've dealt with them and the outcome on the relationships within the family because of those reactions is so drastically different. I found it interesting that both Layla and Sydney had siblings with larger-than-life personalities who stole most of their parents' attention, but while it silenced Sydney's voice, it made Layla grow to be an even stronger and louder presence. In fact, one of the only things in the book that fell flat to me in the novel was the lack of growth and development in Peyton and Sydney's relationship. Sydney and her family (and really, the entire town) spends so much time ruminating on Peyton: his actions, his crime, his sentence. He is the catalyst for so much in Sydney's life, yet I didn't feel a convincing closeness or sense of peace or understanding come between the siblings at the end of the book. The closure at the end felt a little rushed and heavy-handed. The plot itself lacked a certain subtlety that Dessen usually writes with, placing Sydney in uncomfortable situations that she wasn't able to get out of until big, obvious THINGS would happen to sort of smack her and her family into action and realization. Stefani @ Caught Read Handed phrased it best in her review: Saint Anything is loud in what it's trying to say.
One funny yet significant thing I kept hearing about this book is that it had such great descriptions of the perfect summer foods: pizza, french fries, and lollipops. I usually eat pretty healthy, but she had me craving these treats! I also liked seeing how food played a role in everything from social interactions, family business, and job opportunities. I also have to admit that I deeply admired Layla's dedication to her fries, as something of a of fries enthusiast myself.
Overall: Saint Anything holds the classic Sarah Dessen charm of taking stories of quiet, ordinary characters and making them meaningful. I immensely enjoyed spending time with the Chathams, coveting my time with them just as Sydney does. The story also focuses so much on building positive female friendships and unpacking family drama (in both constructive and destructive ways) that it overwhelmed most of the romance, which I didn't seem to mind (it was cute but not critical to the story). I'm so glad I kicked off participating in the #summerofsarahdessen with Saint Anything and glad I found my way back to her novels after several years. Saint Anything won't disappoint seasoned veterans of Dessen's work nor will it let down first time Dessen-readers.
Follow Me: Blog | Twitter | Instagram | Goodreads | Bloglovin'
Reading updates
- Started reading
- 2 June, 2015: Finished reading
- 2 June, 2015: Reviewed