
Metaphorosis Reviews
Written on Jan 28, 2025
Summary
Bannan Larmensu has come to Marrowdell to live with Jenn, whose magic nature means she cannot leave there. But when Bannon's nephews arrive in desperate straits, and with unexpected powers, he and Jenn have to find a way to save his sister despite Jenn's limitations.
Review
I quite liked the first book in this series, A Turn of Light, as a happy, romantic fantasy. This sequel commits fully to that tone. There’s risk and danger, but not too much, and the central lovers never have so much as a tiff. It’s not too credible, but it is light, easy, and interesting.
As is her trademark, Czerneda introduces intriguing beings with unusual cultural and ecological roles. The toads continue to put in an important appearance, though they did feel to me to draw heavily on the Drapsk of her Trade Pact books. If they turn out to be secretly powerful, I think it’ll be an uncomfortably close match.
Jenn continues her development in a logical and satisfying way, edging closer to an understanding of who and what she is, though mysteries remain abundant. All the key characters continue to play their roles – Wisp the dragon and Scourge the kruar. Lila, the sister of Jenn’s lover Bannan comes more to the foreground than in the past, and I found I didn’t care for it. Czerneda relies quite a bit on family bonds, but Lila came across to me as cruel and selfish; the fact that Bannan’s okay with being used didn’t make it any more appealing to me. That’s a bit of a problem, as his quest to help Lila is the core of the book. The politics that causes the quest is very muddled, but it's a pretext for the plot, not a central element.
I recommend this to those looking for sunny (if not always lighthearted), sentimental fantasy. It’s a big book and the plot is on the thin side, but I found myself always happy to pick it up for its sentiment and innovation. There was a surprising number of typos for a ten year old book.