chymerra
Important things you need to know about The Trouble with You:
Pace: Medium
POV: 3rd person (mainly Fannie, but the author occasionally switches to Chloe).
Trigger Warnings: The Trouble with You contains sexism, grief, death, PTSD, and antisemitism. If any of these trigger you, I suggest not reading the book.
Language: There is mild swearing in The Trouble with You. There is also language used that might offend some people.
Setting: The Trouble with You is set in New York City.
Plot Synopsis (as spoiler-free as I can get):
In post-World War II New York City, Fannie lives her best life. Her husband is home from the war. They had just bought a house on the outskirts of New York City and were blissfully happy. But that all ends the night when Max suffers an aneurysm and dies in Fannie’s arms. Now a widow with a small child to care for, Fannie needs to bring income in. She soon lands a job as a secretary for a woman who runs radio serials. There, she is introduced to a whole new world that fascinates her. But, with the blacklist ongoing and HUAC running rampant, she is also afraid that her life could be torn apart as quickly as she built it back up. When one of the writers, a handsome man named Charlie, gets blacklisted, Fannie takes that opportunity to move ahead in her job. But with HUAC breathing down her neck, can Fannie do it? Can Fannie make a life for her daughter and herself and find love? Or will McCarthyism and helping a blacklisted writer be her downfall?
My review:
I rarely read books set in the years between World War II and the Vietnam War. So, when Saint Martin’s Press emailed the widget to me, and I read the blurb, I was very intrigued. I have heard of HUAC and McCarthy mentioned in real life (through documentaries), but I have yet to read a book set in that era. So, I decided to download The Trouble with You. I was pleasantly surprised because this was a fascinating look into the early roots of feminism and going against what society (at that time) expected a woman to be.
The main storyline in The Trouble with You follows Fanny and Chloe throughout their lives. It was a well-written, often heartbreaking story that kept me glued to the book. I ran the gauntlet of emotions while reading, and yes, that is a good thing!!
I enjoy reading books where I can see a character grow from child to adult, and The Trouble with You is that type of book and I got to see that with Chloe. But I also liked seeing how Fanny changed. She went from a grief-stricken young widow who didn’t have any work experience to a woman who wasn’t afraid to take charge and get what she wanted. That was something that I enjoyed reading because the author made it so life-like. Things didn’t happen from Fanny overnight. No, she had to work to get where she was in the radio serial field.
There was romance and a love triangle in The Trouble with You. At one point, Fanny was engaged to one man but in love with another and still grieving her dead husband. It was a cluster. But Fanny sorted it all out and ended up with the right guy.
The angle that explored McCarthyism and HUAC was fascinating to me. As I mentioned above, this was something that I had seen in documentaries. Having a book that had several of the characters deal with the blacklisting and trials was pretty amazing. The author didn’t tone it down, either. I had chills when I read the scene when the HUAC agents interrogated Fanny at her job.
I also liked that there was a feminist angle to the book. I adored Aunt Rose. She was light years ahead of time with some of her views. What she said during the bra-burning scene (at the end of the book) summed her up perfectly.
The end of The Trouble with You was the only part of the book I didn’t like. It did feel a little rushed. While I thought Fanny ended up with the right person, it didn’t gel with me. But other than that, I enjoyed the book.
Many thanks to St. Martin’s Press, St. Martin’s Griffin, NetGalley, and Ellen Feldman for allowing me to read and review this ARC of The Trouble with You. All opinions expressed in this review are mine.