pamela
Written on Feb 12, 2018
The reality is Steal the Stars was a lot more convincing as a podcast than it was a novel. The first person, spoken narrative delivered better. While there were some interesting elements in the way the book was written (it's a mix of first and second person), it was very slow moving and lacked the drive of the podcast. When you hear the character's own voice it is easier to forgive the logical inconsistencies in their development than when written. As soon as words are on the page, there has to be a lot more development of character, motivation and world to convince a reader. The act of reading is slower than audio. There is more time to take in the nuances of a text, and that is something that the novel sorely lacked. The main character's decisions already felt a little incongruous in the podcast, so I was even less convinced by them in the novel.
I fully recommend the podcast, but the book was nothing more than OK. It's not good. It's not bad. It just exists. I am, however, looking forward to seeing if Tor decide to release any more podcasts, and if they do, it would be great to see them really get creative with the cross-platform potential.