pamela
Written on Oct 28, 2012
I wanted so badly to like this book. I'm a Patti Smith fan, and a huge fan of Robert Mapplethorpe's photography, but this book left me completely underwhelmed. Instead of relying on her own ability to write a feeling of time and place, this book read more like a roll call of the who's who of the 60's and 70's. there were mentions of people she never even knew, but were name dropped because they once did something in proximity to an event happening in the narrative. As a biography it seemed weak and untruthful. Many of the memories she shares in the book are written too lyrically to be truthful, and many of her and Robert's less salubrious partakings are given an artistic overhaul to make the seem artistically justified, and therefore above judgement.
Not all bad, there were some valuable insights into the creation of Robert's work, but ultimately I found the book a contrived collection of references to famous people, with only a smattering of artistic depth.