Joséphine
Written on Feb 13, 2017
Actual rating: 3.5 stars
Initial thoughts: Reading Carnivalesque was like staring at a snow globe — it was enthralling but divorced the audience/reader of deeper engagement. The characters came off as shells, especially in comparison to the setting with its mysterious atmosphere. With a plot that seemed to go nowhere half the time, I missed the connection to the characters. While I pitied their plights, I felt a distinct lack of empathy. That distance coupled with a great sense of unknowingness left me floating throughout the book. On an intellectual level, however, Carnivalesque did challenge me. For one, the notion of changelings always begs the question of identity. For another, the prose required full concentration in order to grasp the meaning and various imageries. To me, the setting was what made this book memorable, alongside some of the morbid moments that blurred the lines between the living and the dead.