ladygrey
Written on Dec 30, 2008
But, I didn't entirely love this one. The fact that it's written sort of sideways and rambling can sort of be justified by Jake writing it from scattered notes from years ago, except he doesn't sound like a teenage boy. Maybe I only know this from reading Robin McKinley's blog, but it's completely written in her voice, to the point that at times I had to remind myself it's a story about a teenage boy. Her sideways rambling may be perfectly appropriate for her blog but I know she's capable of being far more eloquent in her novels. I'd like to have seen that. And it got kind of annoying how Jake kept going on and on about how he didn't care if we weren't going to believe him, woo woo, crazy. We're willingly reading a book about dragons, we're going to believe you, move on.
I did really enjoy the story and all the characters, and when I reread it I know I pull more from it, but mostly I remember that it isn't really Jake's book, it's hers.