Jo
Written on Jul 12, 2021
Trigger and content warnings are under spoiler tags.
Trigger/Content Warnings: This book features drug use, animal cruelty, animal death, and rape.
- Summer of Salt by Katrina Leno is a book I've wanted to read for a really long time, so when it was chosen for my book club's June/July read, I was so happy to finally get to it! Unfortunately, I did have some issues with it.
- I absolutely love Leno's writing style. There's an ease to it which is just so enjoyable, you're kind of lulled and swept along on it's tide. It's a writing style I can trust in; no matter what I'll end up thinking of the particular story and plot, if it's written by Leno, I will have a really enjoyable reading experience.
- Summer of Salt is an extremely quirky novel. The plot mainly evolves around Annabella, the only bird of it's kind in existence, believed to have been around for 300 years, that comes to the island of By-the-Sea every summer. The Fernweh's are a family of magical women, who have their own special abilities, and they believe Annabella is one of their ancestors who turned into a bird - hence the bird being named Annabella. Because she's so unique, large numbers of bird watchers flock to the island of By-the-Sea every summer. But this year, Annabella's late. And then her broken body is found. Who killed Annabella, and why? And what is going on with Georgie's sister, Mary, who is suddenly acting strange? It's magical realism, and kind of strange, but I was loving it until the reveal.
- The reveal is something I absolutely feel the need to talk about, because I think it's kind of problematic. So click for spoilers, but people may want to read trigger warnings before reading this book. The big reveal is that at the same time as Annabella was murdered, Mary was raped. And my issue is that I never saw it coming. As I mentioned, I read this for my book club, and we discussed this. The other readers did figure out that Mary had been raped through the hints, but the hints had me thinking something completely different. So while some might see it coming, there could be others who, like me, aren't expecting it at all. It was like a sucker punch - and I don't find it triggering. I can't imagine how it might feel for someone who would find it triggering to not see it coming. I feel if books are about rape and sexual assault, it should be clear from the blurb. People should know in advance what they're reading. Even if others do figure it out from the hints, you don't know before you start reading that this is what the book is about. I feel very strongly that readers should be forewarned. And it's strange, because in the acknowledgements, Leno talks about this book being for those who have been raped or sexually assaulted, but it feels really badly handled to me. I don't think rape should be the big reveal to a mystery. It shouldn't be used as a plot point, in my opinion.
- I loved the queer representation in this book! Georgie is a lesbian; Prue, her love interest is attracted to multiple genders; and Georgie's best friend Vira is ace/aro.
- While I was a little disappointed with the romance - it's a very slow burn, and has very little page-time - I loved how it was handled. By-the-Sea is such a small town, everyone knows Georgie is a lesbian - and that other characters are queer - and it's not a thing. Georgie has never had to question how someone might react to her being a lesbian - and if another girl might be attracted to girls, too - before. Is Prue flirting with her, or is she just friendly? Am I being too flirty? What is she thinking? I loved it.
- I did think Summer of Salt was going to be more witchy than it was. The description had me thinking, as well as having special abilities, the Fernweh women were also witches in general. Potions and spells, herbs and moonlight rituals, etc. But basically, Georgie and Mary's Mum's special ability is creating potions. And while they do come up a few times, it's not really anything major. So I was disappointed with how witchy it wasn't.
- But I really enjoyed all the background aspects to this story, overall. Just the point. The reveal. I personally really wasn't ok with that.
