Reviewed by Leah on
Hold Back The Stars is set in what could be a very real future, in that America is at war (is Katie foretelling the future, considering the president elect? WHO KNOWS) and has mostly gone and Europe is now Europia and residents must Rotate to different Voivode’s (kinda like the districts in The Hunger Games) and love is forbidden until you’re old enough (in your thirties), but when Max & Carys meet, they know waiting that long is just not good enough. Now see, we don’t know this, because the book opens with that damn bad news that Max & Carys apparently only have 90 minutes of air left in their spacesuits, because for some reason THEY’RE IN SPACE. And it’s all gone horribly, awfully, catastrophically wrong. Hence the 90 minutes of oxygen left. It really throws you into the book – you’ve got no idea why they’re 90 minutes away from death, what’s happened to the Earth, why love is banned, nothing. All you know is this book is going to kill you, because even after one page, you care about Max and Carys. You want some kind of miracle to happen, for Carys to figure something out that she hasn’t thought of, and it is literally painful to read and read and read and see their oxygen running out – I don’t even know what to compare it to, it’s that painful. You want to close your eyes and pretend it’s all a dream, or some elaborate plot to prove a lesson to Max or Carys, that it’s just NOT REALLY HAPPENING.
Hold Back The Stars is one of the greatest love stories ever, mostly because it’s the most uncomplicated love story ever. Yes, Max and Carys have some bumps in their road, but it’s not over dramatic, it’s just two people who have grown up to know you can’t fall in love in your twenties and trying to resist it, it’s about overcoming something you’ve known your whole life – like absolutely hating a food, until you try it again and realise it’s not so bad. When you’re programmed to believe love is bad and then meet your soulmate, you’re bound to question if it’s real. What they go through is so real, it comes across the page so well, you really want those two to make it happen, you know that if any two crazy kids can overcome the rules, it’s Max and Carys. You BELIEVE in them, 100%, all the way. I have never in my life felt so invested in characters than I have whilst reading Hold Back The Stars. Never have I wanted so much for it all to go right, to believe that Katie Khan was tricking me, and come the end of this book there would be some amazing miraculous escape (you’ll have to read to find out – sorry!).
I can’t say as much as I want because of spoilers, it’s really hard to not spill my feelings over everything that happens because it would ruin the book. I will say that, for me, it ended with me in happy tears. That’s all your getting. Also: you will cry multiple times while reading, Katie Khan proper tugs at your heartstrings. This book seriously needs to come with its own pack of Kleenex. Hold Back The Stars needs to be a movie. I need to see this on the big screen, I can already imagine it in my mind, it’s that clear to me, and considering I lack an imagination that’s a massive thing for Katie Khan to achieve. Katie is an absolute beast of a storyteller. She’s got all the right ingredients for an absolute whopper of a bestseller, and if you don’t read this book you’re being stupid. It will ruin you and you will love it! I’m getting myself a finished copy the day it comes out firstly because of the stunning cover – LOOK AT IT. I was totally buying the finished copy for the cover anyway because #covergoals but also because of the absolutely amazing story inside. I will be thinking about Max and Carys all the time now, because this is a truly unforgettable story.
Reading updates
- Started reading
- 2 January, 2017: Finished reading
- 2 January, 2017: Reviewed