The Burning of Isobel Key

by Jen McConnel

[Kim Deister]

This was a great book that hit just about every emotion on the scale! Historical fiction isn't generally one of my preferred genres, but this was really a blend of both historical and contemporary times. Lou and Tammy head to Scotland for the holidays on what was a working trip for Tammy. Lou is a bit of a mess, floundering in her life and unsure of where she is going. On a tour, Lou and Tammy meet a gorgeous Highlander named Brian, who inadvertently changes Lou's life. It is by chance that she learns about Isobel and researches her story during the time of the Scottish witch trials. It is then that her life truly changes.

Things to love about Isobel Key...

The cast. The cast is rather small, but it allows you to really get to know the characters. Lou is more than a little unsure of herself, both in life and in love. I really liked her, easily able to empathize with her. Tammy (the BFF) is the epitome of a young, successful woman, completely confident in ways Lou is not. She annoyed me with her judgments throughout the book, although she began to change towards the middle to end of the book. Brian is the sexy Highlander that Lou falls for, although she assumes she has no chance with Tammy nearby. I really liked Brian's character, sweet and kind and no misogyny in sight! Isobel was a character that, for much of the book, was hard to get a handle on. There were parts that made her seem like the victim, others when you had to wonder if she truly was evil. Great suspense! The other characters, though minor, were equally realistic and added a lot to the story.

The storytelling. The way that the author used the back and forth between times essentially told two stories, both Isobel's and Lou's. Although the two wove together to help create Lou's story, Isobel's story was also complete, telling us more of Isobel than just those parts that applied to Lou. It was great to be able to have Isobel as a whole person, with her own complete story.

The witchiness. I love that the portrayal of witchcraft was accurate. Too many times, witchy fiction gets the details wrong or stereotypes it and it changes the feel of the story in a negative way.

The angst. I like how the tension was handled between Tammy and Lou in regards to Lou's Wiccan faith. It was a major conflict point throughout the book and I like that it was used as such and not as a platform that could have taken away from an amazing story.

I like a book that makes me feel, and Isobel Key definitely made me feel. I loved Lou, although her sometimes "wishy washy" demeanor made me want to scream. Tammy frequently annoyed me, as she was supposed to. She reminded me so much of people I have known with her somewhat "holier than thou" attitude. Lou's adopted parents drove me insane, and reminded me a lot of Paige's parents in The Vow, overbearing and controlling. The point is whether you loved them or hated them, these characters drew you into the story. This book really told the story of the witch trials in an interesting way and I enjoyed it from cover to cover!

This review was originally posted at http://thecaffeinateddivareads.multifacetedmama.com/?p=6103.