Reviewed by Kelly on
Let me start by adding that this book isn't at all horribly written, it was actually difficult to put down and I read it almost in one sitting. It isn't the characters themselves as such, but the actual storyline. It's ridiculous. It highlights unprotective sex, cheating, lies, secrets, binge drinking, drug taking, and no parental guidance. Natalie has no backbone, and although she is seemingly happy being on the outside of the teen social scene, all it took was one party and she morphed into a binge drinking idiot. She allows Brooke to plan her life and push her towards dating Eric, even though she has no interest in him whatsoever. Brooke clearly has issues, and neither Natalie or Aiden could take time out from their lives to give her a harsh dose of reality? Without intervening, they've become enablers.
Aiden seems to be the neglected boyfriend who is the only one who is still in the relationship. He's the nice, sensible one who doesn't deserve to be treated as an accessory. But don't be fooled, he's an asshole wrapped in an attractive package. My biggest issue, that although these are very real situations that teens navigate each day through the choices they make, there doesn't seem to be any learning curve here. Just carry on and it'll sort itself out. There are a few instances of living with the consequences of your actions, but considering the intended teen audience, I couldn't see the positive message it should have portrayed. Girls with no self respect, sex that could be considered as rape when one participant has blacked out, the lying, cheating and no fear of repercussions, as there were none.
It really does undo what mothers are trying to instill in their impressionable teen girls. I take no pleasure in writing a negative review, but sadly I can't imagine this book not leaving female readers outraged
Reading updates
- Started reading
- 19 February, 2014: Finished reading
- 19 February, 2014: Reviewed