annieb123's Review of The Phoenix Bride

by Natasha Siegel

“Poetic, romantic, and steeped in seventeenth-century London, The Phoenix Bride is historical fiction at its best.”—Mackenzi Lee, New York Times bestselling author of The Gentleman’s Guide to Vice and Virtue

A passionate tale of plague, fire, and forbidden love from the acclaimed author of Solomon’s Crown

It is 1666, one year after plague has devastated England. Young widow Cecilia Thorowgood is a prisoner, trapped and isolated within her older sister’s cavernous London townhouse. At the mercy of a legion of doctors trying to cure her grief with their impatient scalpels, Cecilia shows no sign of improvement. Soon, her sister makes a decision born of desperation: She hires a new physician, someone known for more unusual methods. But he is a foreigner. A Jew. And despite his attempts to save Cecilia, he knows he cannot quell the storm of sorrow that rages inside her. There is no easy cure for melancholy.

David Mendes fled Portugal to seek a new life in London, where he could practice his faith openly and leave the past behind. Still reeling from the loss of his beloved friend and struggling with his religion and his past, David is free and safe in this foreign land but incapable of happiness. The security he has found in London threatens to disappear when he meets Cecilia, and he finds himself torn between his duty to medicine and the beating of his own heart. He is the only one who can see her pain; the glimmers of light she emits, even in her gloom, are enough to make him believe once more in love.

Facing seemingly insurmountable challenges, David and Cecilia must endure prejudice, heartbreak, and calamity before they can be together. The Great Fire is coming—and with the city in flames around them, love has never felt so impossible.

Originally posted on my blog Nonstop Reader.

The Phoenix Bride is a beautifully written standalone historical novel by Natasha Siegel. Released 12th March 2024 by Penguin Random House on their Dell imprint, it's 336 pages and is available in paperback, audio, and ebook formats. It's worth noting that the ebook format has a handy interactive table of contents as well as interactive links and references throughout.

By turns haunting and poignant, it's less of a romance (though there are elements of forbidden romance, with a slow progression), than a deep examination of healing and grief, set against the great London fire and in the wake of the plague.

The prose is beautifully wrought and is definitely the best part of the book. There's a poetic, dreamlike quality, which comes through even in the most distressing parts (and there are dark and distressing elements - violence, death of a spouse, racism, rigid class systems, and lots of general death).

The overall story arc is positive and full of redemption, but there's a -lot- of melancholy and sadness along the way. Not a very "up" book.

Four stars, gorgeously written with lush and melodic prose, but darned depressing in places. It would likely make a good choice for book club study, public library acquisition, and home reading.

Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher for review purposes.

Reading updates

6 September, 2024: Started reading

6 September, 2024: Finished reading

6 September, 2024: Reviewed