Reviewed by Briana @ Pages Unbound on
I actually did not read any reviews for Truthwitch at all before picking up the book, but that did not allow me to escape from the hype. Promotions and pure, unadulterated love for this book were everywhere in the weeks leading up to its release. I couldn't go on Twitter without getting the impression that Truthwitch would be my new favorite book, a book that would change my life, a book that would be everything. So, sure, part of my critical attitude may be just an adverse reaction to major hype. People set some incredibly high expectations for this book, and I'm not sure anything could have lived up to it. Mostly my issue is that, although technically brilliant, the book never really grabbed my emotions.
Truthwitch is undoubtedly great fantasy. Susan Dennard has put an amazing amount of care into the world-building (almost too much, actually; I thought the details were overwhelming and irrelevant at times) and into the characterizations. Though I didn't end up loving all the characters the way many other readers do, I certainly appreciate them and their complexity. My prime example is love interest Prince Merik. I'm simply not swooning over him, despite his very admirable love for his country and desire to help his people without turning to unethical means. And I'm not swooning in part because he's flawed. He's selfish and self-righteous. He says he's going to do one thing while secretly planning to do another, then gets angry when people act based on what he told them and not on what he intended, as if they're supposed to read his mind. An annoying this itself is, it's even more annoying when the other characters agree with him that they were in the wrong. They weren't. I don't understand some of these characters at all.
And that perhaps is the main problem. I was interested in the characters, as I would be interested in observing people walking on the street. I didn't fall in love with any of them. I could see the relationships Dennard was trying to build, the way she wanted to build a strong female friendship between Iseult and Safiya and the way she wanted to craft a heart-tugging one between Iseult and the mother she could never quite tell loved her. But I wasn't really invested in any of it.
This is consistently the hardest thing for me to explain: why a book doesn't emotionally move me despite apparently having all the correct ingredients. I recommend this book. I think it's really good and, in fact, some of the best YA fantasy I have read in a long time. I just wish I cared a little more and that could pinpoint and articulate the reason I didn't.
Reading updates
- Started reading
- 11 January, 2016: Finished reading
- 11 January, 2016: Reviewed