Origin In Death by J D Robb

Origin In Death (In Death, #21)

by J D Robb

The sickness came into the center of her belly and lay there like a tumor. They've been cloning girls. Not just messing with DNA. But creating them. Selling them.

The world famous cosmetic surgeon, Dr Wilfred Icove, has been found dead - a cold, brutal scalpel to the heart. He is a man with nothing to hide, but when Lieutenant Eve Dallas exposes Dr Icove's patient records, a distressing image appears.

Eve's trail leads to an exclusive boarding school for girls. A strange, isolated place where everything seems perfect. A little too perfect. And when the main benefactor turns out to be a genius geneticist, Eve readies an attack.

With the girls nearing perfection and the men nearing insanity, Eve suspects something truly horrifying is happening . . .

Reviewed by FranJessca @ A Book Lovin' Mama's Blog on

3 of 5 stars

Share

Origin in Death is the twenty-first book in J.D. Robb In Death series. I was glad to be back in the world of Eve, Roarke, Peabody, McNabb, etc. Before diving into these books, I always prepare myself mentally because I know J.D. Robb will make the characters go through some complex cases. This is why I enjoy these books. I have several to catch up on since J.D. Robb is a writing machine and has over 50+ books now in the series. I’m determined to catch up thanks to the #InDeathReadAlong Challenge. 

Storyline/My Thoughts: The minute I read the first chapter in Origin in Death, I knew this book was going to shock me with the crazy storyline. Eve was even baffled when she found Dr. Wilfred Icove stabbed in his office. Here she thinks a professional killed him but reviewing the security footage, and she finds a woman that possibly could be Dr. Icove’s killer. Eve and her team are determined to find the woman and find out why she killed Dr. Icove. Later on, Eve finds Dr. Icove’s son killed the same way. These two doctors, who are well-known reconstructive and cosmetic doctors, have never had a bad record. Eve knows that can’t be true, so she starts looking into their past. She has Roarke dig deeper into the doctors’ pasts, and hopefully, they will find out what had a woman kill them both. The minute they start digging, they realize these doctors are into something that is not legal. It will leave the team wondering how they got away from it for so long. 

There’s also another event happening in the book. Both Roarke and Eve have decided to host Thanksgiving at their house. (Well, Roarke decided, and Eve had to prepare ahead of time mentally.) The best part is Roarke has invited his family from Ireland. Both Roarke and Eve (especially Eve) are nervous to host Roarke’s family that he just met not that long ago. I was excited to have more of Roarke’s family from Ireland because they were interesting when they first came into the series. Although I wish I would’ve had more of Roarke’s family interaction and how Thanksgiving went, there wasn’t much in the book.

Here’s the thing, I liked the book, but it didn’t grab me like previous books have done in the series so far. I’ve mentioned above that I wish I could have more of Roarke and his family from Ireland. I also found the storyline too far-fetched. Here it was the minute Eve, and her team found out what the doctors are really up to and what they have been doing; it makes me wonder why it took so long for someone to catch on to them finally. It takes them being killed to come to light the truth. There was also the issue of the ending and how abrupt it ended. The story reminded me of the movie, The Stepford Wives and how Nicole Kidman uncovers the truth on what has happened to the women in the town she moved to and how they are perfect and obedient. I enjoyed the storyline, but again it was far-fetched at times. I couldn’t believe how no one figured it out. It drove me crazy.

Overall, I give this installment three stars. It may not be my favorite, but other readers may enjoy it. I look forward to diving into the next book because I can’t get enough of this world. I love all the characters and can’t wait to see what case they get next.

Standalone or Part of Series: It’s part of the In Death series, and I would recommend reading in order.

Would I recommend this book? Yes. Even though I gave this book only three stars, it doesn’t mean I won’t recommend it to readers that enjoy this series and love J.D. Robb/Nora Roberts books. 

Last modified on

Reading updates

  • 24 October, 2021: Started reading
  • 24 October, 2021: on page 0 out of 352 0%
  • 3 November, 2021: Finished reading
  • 6 November, 2021: Reviewed