Earth Girl by Janet Edwards

Earth Girl (Earth Girl, #1)

by Janet Edwards

Abandoned on Earth because of her inability to survive on other planets, Jarra crafts a fake background for herself to join a class of norms who are excavating the dangerous ruins of the old cities.

Reviewed by Rinn on

3 of 5 stars

Share
This isn't a proper review, I just want to explain my rating because this book would've been much more highly rated, but for a few things. First of all, what I DID like:
- SPACE ARCHAEOLOGY. Well technically it's all on Earth but yeah. ARCHAEOLOGY.
- The whole premise of the story.
- The universe that it is set in.

BUT:

- The world building was just... uh. Non-existent. Basically everything was portrayed to the reader through HUUUUGE info dumps, and it was all from Jarra answering questions and lecturing her fellow students. No-one except Jarra seemed to know ANYTHING about their own civilisation and the way it was exposed to the reader really bugged me.
- And Jarra. Oh my god. What an insufferable know-it-all. If I was in that class I probably would've punched her in the face in a matter of days. EVERYONE ELSE ON THE COURSE, FORGET ABOUT YOUR DEGREE. JARRA GETS TO DO EVERYTHING BECAUSE SHE'S SPECIAL.



So yeah. I quite liked the story. In fact I liked it a lot. But I just really HATED Jarra and how she constantly lectured everyone - it really dragged the rating down for me.

Last modified on

Reading updates

  • Started reading
  • 11 July, 2014: Finished reading
  • 11 July, 2014: Reviewed