The Belles (the Belles Series, Book 1) (Belles, #1)

by Dhonielle Clayton

[Amber]

I am so, so disappointed by The Belles. It’s possibly one of the most hyped books of the season, and I was really excited to get my hands on it, but it turned out to be a massive disappointment.


I loved the premise and the idea of what message the author was trying to send. The world in this book is basically run on beauty. The rich of Orleans get magical plastic surgery on a whim in order to look younger, look prettier, or just to stand out more. I loved the idea of a group of Belles using arcana to achieve these beauty standards. Unfortunately, the concept wasn’t executed very well at all.

The plot dragged right from the start. The first couple of chapters did nothing to draw me in, and I was bored pretty much from the beginning. I didn’t want to put it down, though, because everyone was talking about the book and I guess I didn’t want to miss out. The ending was slightly better than the beginning of the book, although that’s not saying much at all. If the book was written better, I would have been at least a little bit interested in reading the sequel after reading the ending. Alas.

On the plus side, the main character is black and this is an own voices book, so yay. Maybe others will connect with this more than I did.

That said, the LGBTQIA+ representation in this book is… lacking. There are two prominent queer characters, which would be great since one is the queen, except the book takes a nosedive when it falls into the Bury Your Gays trope. I’m okay with spoiling this because it’s not a nice trope, but if you’re not interested in finding out then you should skip this next bit.

One character, who is a lesbian, is killed in a violent and painful way by two straight characters. It was difficult to read, especially as it went on for a while. The second, the bisexual queen, is killed off-screen. We’re told that she’s dead via a newspaper article, which simply states that her heart has stopped. Nothing more.

I was really disappointed with how this was handled, especially as, as far as I’m aware, these two were the only queer characters in the book.

Like I said, I’m just disappointed by this book in general. I don’t really understand why it’s getting so much love or hype, but I guess other people are getting something from it that I’m not.