Reviewed by phyllish on
There is an ancient Chinese ballad about a maiden who takes her father's place in the Chinese army and saves the day. You are probably familiar with the story from the Disney movie. (I've attempted watching the movie twice but fell asleep both times!)
Author Melanie Dickerson places Mulan in Europe and instead of battling the Huns, she joins the army of a Duke to fight against the Teutonic Knights, a group of militaristic monks. I really appreciated how the author showed who these monks were in such an interesting way that integrated into the story so well.
I don't always relate to strong women characters. Do I believe women should be shy and retiring? Absolutely not! But I don't get women trying to be like men in every way. Mulan was very relateable, though. While she disliked the ""womanly"" arts of cooking and cleaning, preferring to be outdoors and learning archery, she was still very much a woman. She only joined the army out of necessity, to save her mother from eviction. Her strength in the face of fear was very admirable as was her compassion and kindness.
I loved Wolfgang! He is a younger son in the family of the Duke of Hagenheim, the family involved in all the stories of this series. He struggled with feelings of guilt related to an incident in his childhood and subconsciously tried to earn forgiveness. His love for his brother caused him to make some choices that almost got Mulan hurt, and that broke his heart.
There were some beautiful spiritual truths that came out through this narrative as both Mulan and Wolfgang sought to figure out their place in the world.
Most of the story was wonderful, with fun situations and a great picture of what it would have been like for a woman to attempt impersonating a man at that time in history. There was a section, however, pertaining to one of the battles, that seemed to lack some details and appeared a bit abrupt.
If you enjoy young adult fairy tale retellings or even just medieval fiction, I recommend this for your library.
Read my full review with a Preview at Among the Reads
I was given a copy of this book. I was not required to give a favorable review nor was any money received for this review. All comments and opinions are my own.
Reading updates
- Started reading
- Finished reading
- 14 November, 2018: Reviewed