Reviewed by inlibrisveritas on
Let's start with the positives. I really dig the awesome mix of historical fiction with fantasy. I'm a big fan of period novels that have paranormal elements, it brings some new flavor to familiar territory. Plus it's always fun to see how these societies deal with the magic and other oddities. I loved the political play and the rather ragtag nature of the rebellion itself. There are so many novels with a teenager lead armies for freedom, and it gets boring. Thankfully BRR casts a rebellion in a more realistic light and fills it will hasty planning and lofty ideals. The magic system is also rather interesting and really loved the parts centering around the Binding and everything that ties into it (avoiding spoilers here).
But that leads directly into the negatives. I feel that we didn't get a lot of explanation about anything when it comes to the magic. Granted our main character is an outcast to the magical society, so a limited understanding is expected but so much was glossed over. some things that were merely mentioned, almost in passing, become important connects later on and the lack of focus really pulls away from the impact of the reveal. I really wanted to understand the different classes of magic users and their skill sets, but we only get explanations if something is directly used in front of Anna. Which brings me to Anna herself. I kind of hate her. She's not a bad person and she doesn't really insight any anger, but I found her frustrating. Anna acts like a teenager placed in an odd position. She doesn't completely grasp the impact of most situations, she doesn't think things through, and she changes her mind...a lot. She's a teen, it fits the bill...but damn does it get annoying after awhile. I do understand her indecision, as being an outcast with a sudden amount of power could cow most people but it just didn't make for a fun reading experience. Though we get a full story it felt like it was a book that was spending its time spinning its wheels leaving me feeling like not a lot was happening.
Overall I'm not overly impressed with this one. It wasn't a bad read by any means and I definitely see people enjoying it, but this just isn't one that gripped me or made me want to continue the series.
I received this in exchange for an honest review.
Reading updates
- Started reading
- 28 May, 2017: Finished reading
- 28 May, 2017: Reviewed