The Diviners (Diviners, #1)

by Libba Bray

[girlinthepages]

I tried the start The Diviners several years ago (I think in 2013 or 2014), checking it out from the library but quickly returning it unread as I was intimidated by its size. However, I really do love historical fiction and knew a lot of readers who adored the series, so when The Diviners Readalong was announced by some of my favorite folks in the book Youtube community, I knew it would be a great opportunity to finally commit! I decided to tackle these giant tomes via audio book and am so glad I did- it's really the best way to experience these atmospheric stories and the narrator is AMAZING! The stories themselves were really a mix of ups and downs for me, and my ratings were a bit all over the place, but I'm so glad I am in a place now where I am prepared for the fourth and final installment (even if it took me a lot longer than the original readalong schedule lol).



I adored the first book in the series, appropriately named The Diviners. A true paranormal murder mystery, it followed the story of absolutely extra Evie O'Neil as she gets banished to live in New York with her bachelor uncle who is the curator of a paranormal history museum (as one is). Throughout her time in the city she meets several other gifted "diviners" who eventually all get wrapped up in the mystery and murders being committed by a vengeful ghost. The novel definitely focuses on the paranormal but also dives deeply into religion, cults, American history and more, tying all of the elements together so seamlessly that it's easy to believe all of the paranormal stuff actually did happen. Everything about this story, from the plotting to the pacing to the structure was excellently done and I really felt like I was experiencing living in New York in the 1920s.





After ending the first book in the series on such a high note, I was eager to start book 2 (and even did so ahead of schedule). However, my excitement was short lived when I realized that this book was going to have a very different feel than the first one, and focus primarily on dream walking, which can be done by Henry and Ling-Chan. Now, I am REALLY not a fan of stories that just focus on the characters wandering around (a la Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows endless forest scenes) so I knew this book was going to be a tough one for me to get through. While there were some bright spots (I loved the look into 1920s radio with Evie's "sweetheart seer" show, learning more about Sam's backstory, and Henry's as well) most of the story really dragged for me and I found myself totally zoning out a bunch. Even the ending (which was really quite disturbing) bored me because I was just at the point where I was desperate to get through it (at over 20 hours on audio it's a real commitment). I think I'm probably in the minority here since a lot of people loved this book, but it really didn't have the elements of the first installment that I enjoyed so much.





I'll admit, I was a bit weary going into the third book of this series, after I had a hard time with the second. I didn't need to worry though, as I actually ended up really enjoying it! In this installment the gang truly felt like they were a family and all of their story lines have started to become interconnected. The past also begins to merge with the present in this book as Evie & Co. begin to find out how they became Diviners and how they were all drawn to New York, and how Will plays into all of it. There's quite a bit of government intrigue that plays into the plot, and while readers are led to believe by the synopsis and the first half of the book that the setting is going to be an asylum off the coast of New York, the story is so much more than a creepy asylum tale. It's a story of found family, of unearthing the horrors of America (even the non-paranormal ones that actually happened, like eugenics and white supremacy). It's hard to say more without spoilers, but I feel like this book finally caught the series' stride from turning away from a paranormal murder mystery (which is what the first book reads like to me) and pivoting into a full-blown save the world saga.

Minor spoiler ahead, but there were also quite a few deaths at the end of this book, that all happened one after another like domino pieces falling. Perhaps I was naive, but I wasn't expecting that after the core gang has been intact for two entire lengthy books. There were two deaths in particular that really caught me off guard, and one of those was pretty upsetting, (but I hope it motivates the rest of the Diviners into action)! We also got quite a bit of Sam in this book which I adored because he's my favorite character after Theta (who grew so much in this book)! Overall I think Bray packed a LOT of trauma into the ending of this one to prepare for a more somber tone in The King of Crows.This review was originally posted on Girl in the Pages