Reviewed by Berls on
I feel like this is perhaps harder than some of my favorite Austen books to bring to life, because so much of what happened to the characters has to do with the time they were living in. And yet, Staci Hart found a really great way to give those situations a modern spin. I absolutely loved Annie (modern version of Marianne), her zest for life and being driven by her sensabilities really made her an endearing character... perhaps more so than the original? And it was a treat to get some of the story from Greg's (modern Colonel Brandon) point of view - something that you don't get in the original. I couldn't help but compare him to Alan Rickman's performance though and how do you live up to that? All said, he was a great character who I had no trouble rooting for. Staci Hart captured his sensitive and guarded soul well.
Looking at other reviews I keep noticing people complaining about the "random love triangle" and I'm feel bad for Staci Hart that they giving her a ding on that when that's IN THE ORIGINAL. If she hadn't had the Willoughby character it wouldn't have been Sense and Sensiblity! So not only do I not take away stars for it, but applaud her taking what was a triangle steeped in problems related to their time and modernizing it to make Willoughby an equally problematic character.
My one complaint (that you don't see in other reviews because I think they are not aware of the retelling the way I am...) is that the romance of Eleanor and Edward barely registers. I don't even remember their names in this version. And yeah, I get this is a retelling but honestly the book is Sense and Sensiblity because Marianne and Eleanor are foils of each other. And Marianne's romance is the more dramatic one but Eleanor's romance is a quiet, heartbreaking, beautiful one and I was really sad to not see it beyond a couple mentions in this book.
The narration was absolutely perfect. James Cavenaugh and Carly Robins delivered really solid characters AND complimented each other beautifully. This is my first book wtih both of them together, though I have listened to Carly Robins on her own previously. I think this is my first time - but not last I hope! - with James Cavenaugh. I enjoyed their performance and wouldn't hestiate to listen to either again - solo or paired.
Reading updates
- Started reading
- 22 June, 2022: Finished reading
- 22 June, 2022: Reviewed