Smoky the Cowhorse by Will James

Smoky the Cowhorse

by Will James

In language that truly evokes the Wild West, Smoky the Cowhorse brings to life one horse's story, from his birth on the open range through his breaking to Smoky's other lives as an outlaw rodeo star and saddle horse. A Newbery Medal Book. 40 illustrations.

Reviewed by Liz (Bent Bookworm) on

1 of 5 stars

Share
DNF. The writing style is absolutely horrible. I think the author is trying to imitate in writing what he believes to be an Old West accent and mannerisms. In narrative style. It's insulting, even to young readers. I am completely flummoxed as to how this book, in a world that already had classics like Little Women, with beautiful prose, could have chosen this for any type of award, ever. I'll keep it just to have a complete (one day) collection of the Newbery awards, but would never, ever recommend it for any child to read. I couldn't even get through it as an adult, it felt like a total waste of my time.

Last modified on

Reading updates

  • Started reading
  • 29 June, 2016: Finished reading
  • 29 June, 2016: Reviewed