Reviewed by Baroness Book Trove on

5 of 5 stars

Share
I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy from the Author. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

Can the Carson family lay low long enough to get to 1983?


Caitlin's Song by John A. Heldt is an intriguing book as we find ourselves gaining knowledge that we know hasn't happened yet for these characters. The Carson clan is in two different years throughout the entire storyline and has to figure out a ton of things that could help or not help them in the long run.

What I liked:



  • Caitlin is the main focus on the Carson siblings in this one. She is a great character that has grown since the first book. Caitlin is also my favorite character.

  • The siblings all being in Colorado. It was nice to see Colorado in the sixties through their eyes.

  • The parents being on two missions. I can't precisely say what one of them is but the other is still to reunite with their ever-growing family.

  • Some scenes, when we follow Cody, are hilarious.


What I didn't like


The first thing that I didn't like was that a sibling got murdered. That was just so terrifying. Another dislike is the way that Natalie reacted to the news that the twins gave her. I dislike the way that a fraternity member was trying to get Cody to join their fraternity. Then there is the way that Molly acted at times to the twins and telling on Caitlin to Vince.

Five Stars


Caitlin's Song by John A. Heldt is a marvelous book about finding love, having an adventure, and learning about new opportunities, along with many more things. The Carson family had their ups and downs in here, but they made it to another year. They are now one step closer to finding their parents and heading home. To which year, we have no clue.


Other Books in the Series


River Rising


by John A. Heldt 
Series: Carson Chronicles #1 
Published by Amazon on September 20, 2017 
Genres:  Historical, New Adult Fiction, Romance, Historical Romance
Pages: 661
Format: Kindle
Buy on Amazon
My Review
Weeks after his parents disappear on a hike, Arizona engineer Adam Carson, 27, searches for answers. Then he discovers a secret web site and learns that his mother and father are time travelers stuck in the past. Armed with the information he needs to find them, Adam convinces his younger siblings to join him on a rescue mission to the 1880s. 

While Greg, the adventurous middle brother, follows leads in the Wild West, Adam, journalist Natalie, and high school seniors Cody and Caitlin do the same in Johnstown, Pennsylvania. Like the residents of the bustling steel community, all are unaware of a flood that will destroy the city on May 31, 1889. 

In RIVER RISING, the first novel in the five-book Carson Chronicles series, five young adults find love, danger, and adventure as they experience America in the age of bustle dresses, gunslingers, and robber barons.

The Memory Tree


by John A. Heldt 
Series: Carson Chronicles #2 
Published by Amazon on April 30, 2018
Genres:  Historical, New Adult Fiction, Romance, Historical Romance
Pages: 659
Format: Kindle
Buy on Amazon
My Review
Days after barely escaping 1889 with their lives, the Carsons, siblings from the present day, resume their search for their missing parents in 1918. While Adam and his pregnant wife, Bridget, settle in Minnesota, unaware of a wildfire that will kill hundreds, Greg seeks clues in his great-grandparents' Mexico, where he finds love, danger, and enemies. At the same time, Natalie, the ambitious journalist, follows a trail to World War I France, and teen twins Cody and Caitlin rekindle a friendship with an old Pennsylvania friend haunted by her past. In THE MEMORY TREE, the sweeping sequel to RIVER RISING, several time travelers find answers and meaning as they continue the adventure of a lifetime in the age of doughboys, silent movies, and Model T's.

Indian Paintbrush


by John A. Heldt 
Series: Carson Chronicles #3 
Published by Amazon on November 26, 2018
Genres:  Historical, New Adult Fiction, Romance, Historical Romance
Pages: 659
Format: Kindle
Buy on Amazon
My Review
Arizona, December 1943. After surviving perilous six-month journeys to 1889 and 1918, the Carsons, five siblings from the present day, seek a respite in their home state. While Adam and Greg settle down with their Progressive Era brides, Natalie and Caitlin start romances with wartime aviators and Cody befriends a Japanese family in an internment camp. The time travelers regroup, bury some ghosts, and continue their search for their missing parents. Then old problems return, new ones emerge, and a peaceful hiatus becomes a race for survival. In INDIAN PAINTBRUSH, the sequel to RIVER RISING and THE MEMORY TREE, several young adults find love and adventure as they navigate the home front during the height of World War II.



Thank you for dropping by! I hope you enjoyed this review of Caitlin's Song by John A. Heldt. 

Until the next time,



Happy Reading!

This review was originally posted on Baroness' Book Trove

Last modified on

Reading updates

  • Started reading
  • 29 August, 2019: Finished reading
  • 29 August, 2019: Reviewed