Sworn to Silence by Linda Castillo

Sworn to Silence (Kate Burkholder, #1)

by Linda Castillo

Some secrets are too terrible to reveal . . .

Some crimes are too unspeakable to solve . . .

Painter's Creek, Ohio may be a sleepy, rural town with both Amish and 'English' residents, but it's also the place where a series of brutal murders shattered the lives of an entire community over a decade ago. When the killing stopped, it left in its aftermath a sense of fragility, and for the young Amish girl, Katie Burkholder, a realization that she didn't belong.

Now, 15 years, two dead parents and a wealth of experience later, Katie has been asked to return as Chief of Police. Her Amish background combined with her big-city law enforcement expertise make her the perfect candidate. Katie is certain she has come to terms with the past. Until the first body of a slaughtered young woman is found in a pristine, snowy field...

Reviewed by readingwithwrin on

3 of 5 stars

Share
3.5 stars

"A female chief of police was rare, especially in a small town. An Amish cop was unheard of."


Warning: This book contains Rape, Murder, and gory details about the murders.


Last year I accidently read the 4th book in this series, so I did end up knowing some things, but it didn't affect the story up until the last few pages.

Kate Burkholder is the chief of police, in small town Ohio, on top of that she is also ex-amish and has a secret that she has kept hidden since she was 14. When a woman turns up raped, tortured, and murder with roman numerals carved into her stomach, Kate fears that someone from 16 years ago is back. While this not only shocks the town it also brings back old fears and makes the whole town on edge. But with Kate's judgment impaired with a fear that she knew who the killer is, she doesn't ask for help soon enough and the town council end up taking matters into their own hands calling in the sheriffs department and BCI.

I love how strong of a character Kate is and how, despite being raised Amish she isn't angry at them, and has been able to maintain a pretty good relationship with them even though she is under the Bann. She still has the strong morals that they did and is still slightly naive to what can happen in non-amish life.
I did struggle at times to believe the person from her past was the one who could possibly be doing the murders though and I found that part of the story to be a wild goose chase since no one had heard from the man since it happened.

It was a huge contrast to see John Tomasetti (BCI) how he was in this book as an alcoholic, pill-popper who, is on the verge of losing his job. It was actually sad at times since I already knew what kind of person he has become now.

I really did enjoy seeing how their relationship came to happen and why they both act the way they do.

I never once thought it would be who it was though, I figured it would have been someone from the Council since they were always getting over involved and trying to take over the case.
I did start having suspicions though right before Kate figured it out, so it was nice to know that I wasn't to far-off. I could have done without some of the details from a few of the crime scenes since they can get pretty graphic at times.

But overall I still enjoy this series and I can't wait to read the next one.

See more reviews like this on my blog

Last modified on

Reading updates

  • Started reading
  • 1 June, 2015: Finished reading
  • 1 June, 2015: Reviewed