Reviewed by zooloo1983 on
Again, set mere weeks after the last book, you are wondering if Audrey-Rose and Thomas may have a breather. They are on the RMS Etruria, on a week-long voyage to America to help assist Audrey’s Uncle on a case. Whilst relaxing in first class, they are treated to a circus act during dinner where things turn rather….deadly.
With being confined on a boat and women going missing, it intensifies the claustrophobia. Literally, in the middle of a vast ocean, people dying, knowing there is a murderer on the ship, who do you trust? Who can you trust? What could be more terrifying than that? It made the fear in the passengers more palpable, and I know Escaping from Houdini is set years before the sinking of the Titanic, I still could not stop worrying about it!
I love how each book focuses on a new infamous person, this time with “Harry” Houdini. He did not feature as much as I would have hoped, and Maniscalco said at the end of the book she had changed parts of his history to fit with the story. This did not affect the story in any way, because it was exciting to see him perform his escapes on the boat. I love the circus, so I was drawn straight away to the Illusionist and the rest of the Moonlight Carnival. I mean this sounds so mystical and to be honest sinister add the boat and you do have a recipe for disaster.
I have to shout out to Nicola Barber AGAIN! She just blows my mind with her narrations!! Every time I listen, I forget it is her doing all the voices, you feel like there is a team of people with her. She gets every emotion spot on, she can ramp up the mystery and horror all with her voice. Even if you are not interested in the book, you should listen just for her!!
Check out a snippet here!
Mephistopheles is a new and exciting character in this instalment. Albeit I did not like the love triangle side of things but had Audrey been as free as she would like they would have made a great pairing. (Still Thomas for me!) He too is a scientist of sorts, so this appeals to Audrey as she undertakes a secret mission to work with him to help his carnival and to find the true murderer. The retorts between Mephistopheles and Thomas were fun to read, but at the same time, I will always be #teamThomas and was not impressed with the way he was being treated and portrayed.
Buuuutttt on the flip side of this, the conflict Audrey goes through shows very real and human emotions. Her heart is for Thomas, but the excitement and danger with Mephistopheles opened her eyes to what could lay in the future? Causing doubt and conflict in both her heart and mind left the reader feeling a bit bereft to what she might follow. How could Audrey doubt everything she had been through with Thomas, after a few days of being in the company of Mephistopheles. Hrmph! Oh! and the other bugbear, there was not enough Thomas Cresswell in this book!
Saying all of the above, yes the love story was a chunk of this story, but the gruesome murders and the thrill of playing detective is still such a pivotal role in this book. The boat itself is such a huge character in the story, discovering new ways to stay hidden. Who is feeding the animals part of the human remains? Who is staging the murders to look like the tarot cards? More importantly, and a little bit more scary to think about… Were there two murderers?
Well the last question, we will not get an answer to until September when the last book in the series Capturing the Devil is released. I might cry at this!!
Reading updates
- Started reading
- 3 July, 2019: Finished reading
- 3 July, 2019: Reviewed
- Started reading
- 3 July, 2019: Finished reading
- 3 July, 2019: Reviewed