Reviewed by Hillary on
The thing that struck me most about this book is how awesome the artwork is. Which was great cause other parts of the story was.... Ummm.... needed work. I loved how the sisters got along with each other, and I loved that there was an interracial couple in the book what I did not love was how they portrayed the disabled little girl?
Like she was on the outside of everything. She did not even have her friends, and she did look and sound to be school age, and even if she wasn't why did she still not have her friends? Not all disabled children are outcasts. Ane the way she is made to appear like she would break at any moment and can't go out or do anything because of her lungs. I had issues with that also.
The romance between the older sister and the neighbor boy while cute was unrealistic. I know that in fiction one has to suspend belief to get the story and I get that. I had no trouble suspending belief with the ghost story line for example but the insta love that took place just grated on my nerves. I HATE the insta-love trope no matter where it is played out.
[Tweet "the artwork was awesome but it had some tired tropes that made it less than enjoyable"]
I enjoyed the artwork in this comic even if I thought most of the plot needed a lot more work before being published, so it was wasn't a total waste of time reading this. It only took me about an hour to get through so no biggie.This review was originally posted on Adventures in Never Never Land
Reading updates
- Started reading
- 11 February, 2017: Finished reading
- 11 February, 2017: Reviewed