Reviewed by clementine on
I was nervous going into this one because I remembering adoring it when I was younger, and I didn't want it to be ruined. Luckily, it was not ruined, and I still absolutely loved it.
The premise of this book is incredibly inventive, and Zevin does it justice. The writing isn't stunning, but there are some really nice passages and it has an overall lyrical feel to it which is quite pleasant. The characters seem fully fleshed out and real, even though many of them don't really have much "screen time" as it were. I absolutely love Curtis Jest, and he isn't really a main character. Aldous Ghent was also fantastic, and his whimsy reminded me of both The Phantom Tollbooth and A Series of Unfortunate Events. None of the romance feels forced or unnecessary; it's just really nice and heartwarming. And, in general, I found this book to be quite emotional, but in an understated way, so that none of it is contrived.
It's not perfect; it's a first novel, and I think that's pretty obvious in places. The writing can be a bit clunky at times (although like I said, it's generally quite nice). The opening chapter is actually the weakest part of the entire book, and I think might turn some people off reading it. But in general, I think this is a very lovely book.
Reading updates
- Started reading
- 3 November, 2012: Finished reading
- 3 November, 2012: Reviewed