I've read a lot of Melanie Marks books and I think i like this one the best!!! Sometimes, the girls in the books seem a little whinny and over reacting so it was nice to get a (sorta) down to earth guy. Even though his problems are rather vague in the book, you can still connect with him and understand how he feel. Really Really liked his take and his (sorta) BFF Mason was hilarious too (but maybe its because i read his book.hmmm....) only complaint? Too short!! (Jk but not really) It was standard book length, but I wanted more!! more info, more back story!! So in conclusion, even though it tended to get a little repetitive, it was still a success.