Beth C.
Robinson, as most know, is the first openly gay Bishop of any faith in the United States. As such, he does have an underlying desire to see gay marriage become commonplace and DOMA disappear. And he makes no bones about how being gay and not allowed to wed for so long affected his life. However, he does get into scholarly research, as well as many explanations with regards to the history of the Bible and those within it. It was interesting to read many things I never knew, and how important context is to even the words of Jesus himself.
The only downside to the book is that Robinson does tend to repeat himself a little more than I would like, but I'm guessing it has to do with how the book was put together. Each chapter is about one main argument/question, and his rebuttal/answer. So naturally, some of the answers will tend to overlap a little bit.
For me, the mark of a good nonfiction book is whether it makes me ask more questions, and gives me the desire to do more research myself. This book did that. Again, I'm all for gay marriage, and I agree with the fact that it is a civil rights issue NOT a religion issue. Or shouldn't be, anyway. It was the history and the context he used during his arguments that had me fascinated and wanting to learn more.
This is a book well worth reading, regardless of where you stand. He makes rational, thought-out arguments, that at the very least might make you think a bit more. I want to have a copy on hand so I can go back to the conversation when words fail me in the future :)