Berls
To be honest, I almost DNF'd Illuminae. There were a few reasons -- I had a lot going on in my personal life and was perhaps not in the best place to be reading this book, I wasn't drawn to the VERY YA characters, and the plot initially lost me. I usually make my decision to DNF a book at the 20% mark, but I gave it a little longer because of my mindset and I am glad that I did. I ultimately found that last 25% ish very engaging and I can see why the series is so popular. Just a very slow start.
I think it was at about 35% that I got really interested. The artificial intelligence made things interesting and the illness presented an unexpected complication/twist. I really never did get to where I truly cared about any of the characters though. Kady was somehow simultaneously smart and dumb, selfless and selfish. So yeah, a YA character.
The way the story was told - though snippets of an investigation looking back at what happened - probably had a lot to do with how I felt disconnected and impersonal. I can see why it was done that way and it had definite advantages, but it did keep me from really connecting with the characters, I think.
The narration possibly added to that disconnect. It is one of those performances that has tons of narrators playing different roles, complete with sound effects and everything - a true theatrical experience. And it was definitely a solid performance, something I typically consider to be a treat. But in this instance, I think that it added to the feeling of disconnect. I never forgot that I was listening to recordings of events and stayed disconnected from the characters. I don't know, I think everyone delivered a solid performance and if this is your kind of book I think I would definitely recommend the narration.
All that said, if the story were continuing in the next book I'd probably read on. But it appears to be rehashing of events from different POVs and I'm really not interested in revisiting this story. So that will be it for me.