Since We Fell

by Dennis Lehane

'Complex, tense, compelling' Lee Child

'Hitchcockian...with characteristically twisty action and crackling dialogue' Guardian Best Crime & Thriller Books of 2017

On a Tuesday in May, in her thirty-fifth year, Rachel shot her husband dead. He stumbled backward with an odd look of confirmation on his face, as if some part of him had always known she'd do it.

Rachel's husband adores her. When she hit rock bottom, he was there with her every step of the way as she slowly regained her confidence, and her sanity. But his mysterious behaviour forces her to probe for the truth about her beloved husband.

How can she feel certain that she ever knew him?

And was she right to ever trust him?

Bringing together Dennis Lehane's trademark insightful and emphathetic characterisation, razor-sharp dialogue, stunning atmosphere and breakneck twists and turns, Since We Fell is a true masterpiece that will keep you in suspense until the very end.

• ISBN10: 0062129414
• ISBN13: 9780062129413
• Publish Date: 9 May 2017
• Publish Status: Active
• Publish Country: US
• Publisher: HarperCollins Publishers
• Imprint: Collins
• Edition: Large type / large print edition
• Format: Paperback (US Trade)
• Pages: 608
• Language: English

Reviews

[jamiereadthis]

This is going to be one of those books I can’t stop reading. Third time through and it gets better and better. I’ve waited my whole life for a book that does this exact thing.

A small, strange fire grew in his eyes. “No one’s got long game anymore. Everyone wants it now.”

---

First read September 2017:

It’s two books smashed together, that’s announced right on the jacket, and that’s all I knew going in. The first part was good, but just good, the kind of book that would interest me while I read it but that I would mostly forget once I’m done.

But then. THEN. The second half of the book. It’s ridiculous. It’s impossible. It not only goes off the rails, it does that thing where a train goes off the rails but has so much momentum it plows through the earth for a mile. And I love it. It’s the stuff my dreams are made of. I laughed out loud, I swore out loud, I turned the last page and wanted to read it again.

Your own mileage may vary, depending on how much belief you can suspend. But that’s what I love about fiction. Done right, anything’s possible. And I’ll suspend all the belief in the world if I get long cons and heists and love, hate, and trust.

[Quirky Cat]

I'm going to be honest with you here; I came very close to putting this book down and not finishing it. I ended up being stubborn and not letting myself do that, which I'm glad for. I didn't end up loving it but the feeling and events change pretty dramatically, and I would have missed all of that if I hadn't continued reading. Despite all this, it's actually written very well. Some authors can't write accurately for the opposite gender, causing a break in the immersion. Lehane doesn't have this problem – not once did I find myself questioning Rachel's way of thinking (outside of the norm for a charater like her that is). I imagine this is difficult to do, and I would like to give Lehane the credit for it.



Warnings first: Rachel spends some time in Haiti, during which she reveals she tried to help a group of four girls safely avoid a bunch of rapists. She fails to protect them, leading to a lot of guilt. It's heavily implied that the girls taken were raped and murdered. Because of Rachel's guilt about this, it comes up frequently.
Since We Fell starts out feeling almost more like literary fiction than thriller, which is interesting. Rachel Childs had an uneasy childhood, not necessarily a bad one, but still not a fantastic one. That bleeds into her adult life, and likely affects her way of thinking and acting. She ends up becoming a reporter, but later, thanks to her anxiety, she loses her job, her husband, and her friends (clearly they weren't very good friends, but that's beside the point). She manages to start getting her life back on track again thanks to Brian, her future second husband.
It's at this point that the novel feels like it flips a switch, and suddenly becomes a thriller instead. It turns out that lovely, wonderful, caring Brian is actually a con-man; has been their entire relationship. His actions end up putting himself, Rachel, and his business partners/friends in mortal danger.
Personally, I found the first half (before the sudden transition) to be a bit slow and dry. There was an awful lot of buildup, and I'm not sure it was worth it in the end. Did it help me get into Rachel's head more? I'm sure, but what I'm not sure about is if that was actually needed.
The thriller half of the book (as I'd like to consider it) was a bit less organized, but in a good way. It was chaotic and had constant movement and changes, causing the reader to be uncertain about what was going to happen next, or how Rachel would get out of it. I got a little confused at one point, where Rachel was imagining the worst case scenario of one of her actions. It took me a moment to realize what was actually going on versus what she was afraid of. Once I got past that moment though, things went pretty well.
On the whole I don't regret reading Since We Fell, but I still maintain that it almost felt as if it were two separate books that just happened to have the same main characters. I like the second half much more than the first, though still acknowledge that the first part was well written, if a bit dry. Lehane is very talented at getting into a fictional character's head, and ripping out all the details for the world to see. It's probably worth noting that this is the first of his works that I've read; I liked his writing style enough to want to go take a peek at what else he has done.


For more reviews, check out Quirky Cat's Fat Stacks