Beth C.
I started out a bit hesitant about the book - curious, but not really convinced that bird pirates would be a good idea. My lack of conviction died about half way through, and stayed buried until the end. It really is a well-written story, and uses the real-life qualities of the birds to accent their characters within the book. It is apparent that the author enjoys birds and has a pretty decent knowledge base with which to draw from. The story start a little bit slow, but picks up speed and keeps a pretty good pace the rest of the way through. The illustrations are lovely - my Vine edition didn't have color, but the black and white versions were pretty darn wonderful. I'm sure the color will be even better.
As a teacher, I found so many things that could be pulled from the book for further discussion/exploration. Friendship, bullying, being yourself, science (the different kinds of birds, star-nosed moles, migration, etc.), fables (there is one in the book about how the crow lost it's voice and became black)...these are just a few of the topics I can pick out right off the top of my head. The nice thing is that unlike some books with multiple topics, there isn't any preaching. It's just a good story that kids will enjoy with some added information.
I would definitely recommend this book. I believe it would appeal to both boys and girls, probably in the 3-6 grade range. Even better, it would be extremely well-suited for out loud reading, both in the classroom and at home. The ending certainly concludes this story, but also seems to leave open the possibility that this could be a series. I can say with no hesitation that I would enjoy reading another tale of Blue Jay and his pirate crew!