Metaphysics, Sophistry, and Illusion: Toward a Widespread Non-Factualism

by Mark Balaguer

0 ratings • 0 reviews • 0 shelved
Book cover for Metaphysics, Sophistry, and Illusion

Bookhype may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure.

Metaphysics, Sophistry, and Illusion does two things. First, it introduces a novel kind of non-factualist view, and argues that we should endorse views of this kind in connection with a wide class of metaphysical questions, most notably, the abstract-object question and the composite-object question. (More specifically, Mark Balaguer argues that there's no fact of the matter whether there are any such things as abstract objects or composite objects-or
material objects of any other kind.) Second, Metaphysics, Sophistry, and Illusion explains how these non-factualist views fit into a general anti-metaphysical view called neo-positivism, and explains how we could argue that neo-positivism is true. Neo-positivism is the view that every metaphysical question
decomposes into some subquestions-call them Q1, Q2, Q3, etc.-such that, for each of these subquestions, one of the following three anti-metaphysical views is true of it: non-factualism, or scientism, or metaphysically innocent modal-truth-ism. These three views can be defined (very roughly) as follows: non-factualism about a question Q is the view that there's no fact of the matter about the answer to Q. Scientism about Q is the view that Q is an ordinary empirical-scientific question
about some contingent aspect of physical reality, and Q can't be settled with an a priori philosophical argument. And metaphysically innocent modal-truth-ism about Q is the view that Q asks about the truth value of a modal sentence that's metaphysically innocent in the sense that it doesn't say anything
about reality and, if it's true, isn't made true by reality
  • ISBN10 0198868367
  • ISBN13 9780198868361
  • Publish Date 26 January 2021
  • Publish Status Active
  • Publish Country GB
  • Imprint Oxford University Press
  • Edition 1
  • Format Hardcover
  • Pages 320
  • Language English