Murder on Thames: A Cherringham Cosy Mystery (Cherringham Series, #1) (Cherringham Cosy Mystery, #1)

by Matthew Costello and Neil Richards

• ISBN10: 1913331547
• ISBN13: 9781913331542
• Publish Date: 12 June 2020 (first published 18 September 2018)
• Publish Status: Active
• Publish Country: GB
• Imprint: Red Dog Press
• Format: Paperback (US Trade)
• Pages: 126
• Language: English

Reviews

[kimbacaffeinate]

Murder on Thames: Cherringham, Episode 1 – Is the first episode of the cosy crimes series, Cherringham. Cherringham is a quiet town in the Cotswolds and begins a series that will feature Jack Brennan, a former NYPD homicide detective and Sarah Edwards, a single mother of two who works with technology.

Sarah has just returned to her hometown of Cherringham, and Jack has retired there enjoying time on his boat with his dog and a good drink. When Sarah’s friend is found dead and everyone assumes it was an accident, Sarah begins asking questions. While walking the river’s edge she meets Jack and questions him. He of course wants nothing to do with it, but after she leaves he begins thinking about what she said the police reported and that was highly unlikely. Thus, the two begin investigating.

As far as cases go, this had a Jessica Fletcher vibe, but was all rather easy to solve. Since it’s a novella and the start of a rather long serial I am ok with that. It had a nice set up, I liked the characters and the building relationships.

Neil Dudgeon narrated and did a fine job with the different characters from key players to suspects. While, I don’t think Jack’s NY accent was completely spot on, I am sure many a Brit have felt the same regarding American narrators. It was close enough and didn’t make me wince. Mostly my issue was with a few key words. Having said that I would happily listen to more of his audiobooks.

The Cherringham Serial has over 34 episodes and it looks like the Audiobooks are bundled into 3 to 4 episodes giving the listener 6-8 hours of enjoyment. (although some can be purchased individual) This review was originally posted at Caffeinated Reviewer

[jesstheaudiobookworm]

3.5 ★ Audiobook⎮The snobby little Anglophile within me has been rearing its head lately, causing me to turn up my nose at all things American and crave BBC TV Dramas and cozy village mysteries. I decided to pick up the first Cherringham compilation because it consists of three separate mystery stories, called “episodes”, each one only being a couple of hours long.

My thinking was that if I didn’t enjoy the first mystery, I would have only wasted a couple of hours of my time and still completed an episode. That wound up being my favorite thing about the Cherringham mysteries, their brevity. Each episode was the literary equivalent of a single serving dish. What was lacking in coziness and intrigue was made up for in succinctness.

The overall character of the village of Cherringham fell a little flat, as did its main character. Though, not for a lack of potential. I actually think the short length of each episode harmed the series by stunting its growth potential. I wouldn’t have a minded an extra hour or so of listening if it had been devoted to more development, outside of each mystery.

As it was, I can’t complain too much, because I was interested (or just bored) enough to continue listening to the remaining two episodes in the compilation. I happen to have been also watching the BBC series Midsomer Murders on Netflix around the same time I was listening to this series and the comparison of American ex-cop Jack (from the stories) to Chief Inspector Barnaby (from Midsomer Murders) is a significant stretch. I can see how the authors would have wanted to re-create the appeal of Midsomer Murders, but they were missing a certain je ne sais quois.

If you’re looking for an “edge of your seat” mystery or a “cozy night in” series, this probably isn’t it. However, if you’re looking to pass a few hours of time, have at it. This compilation was far from terrible, but it wasn’t exactly memorable it either. It’s not really something I see myself returning to in the future.
Narration review: The authors were pushing for a Midsomer Murders vibe hard. So hard that they actually hired the actor who plays Chief Inspector Barnaby to narrate the audiobooks. Aside from the brevity, Neil Dudgeon’s performance was my favorite thing about listening to Cherringham. His performance did more to imbue the series with a feeling of coziness than the stories themselves. If I were to ever pick up another Cherringham episode, it would be to hear him narrate. ♣︎