A Shot in the Dark: A Constable Twitten Mystery (A Constable Twitten Mystery, #1)

by Lynne Truss

Constable Twitten investigates the death of a famed theater critic who was murdered before he could deliver information about an unsolved crime.

• ISBN10: 1635570557
• ISBN13: 9781635570557
• Publish Date: 6 November 2018 (first published 28 June 2018)
• Publish Status: Out of Print
• Out of Print: 14 March 2024
• Imprint: Bloomsbury Publishing
• Format: Hardcover
• Pages: 304
• Language: English

Reviews

[annieb123]

Originally published on my blog: Nonstop Reader.

A Shot in the Dark is the first book of a new series set in 1950's Brighton. Based on Lynne Truss' BBC Radio 4 series with some of the same characters, this novelization is a decidedly odd & farcical lampooning of post-WW2 police procedurals.

Released 6th Nov 2018 by Bloomsbury, it's 304 pages and available in hardcover, paperback, ebook and audio formats.

The author has an unerring ear for dialogue and setting. The book really reads exactly like it was written contemporaneously for the time in which it's set. The pacing is superb and it moves along at a good clip. I never found my interest flagging. Ms. Truss has a deft touch with characterizations (she's been writing these characters for a while for audio plays, and it shows).

That being said... for an almost cozy read, there is a prodigious amount of violence (much of it gratuitous). People are constantly being stabbed, slashed, shot, throttled, flung out of amusement park rides into the ocean, run over, and otherwise mutilated. There is a disconcerting amount of *glee* in the descriptions. There is a bizarrely psychotic Punch & Judy man who is both hysterically funny and scary in about equal measure.

The language is way over the top. The violence is omnipresent. I personally loved the denouement, but readers who need everything to be tied up in a neat bow with the good guys the unequivocal winners by page 298 are going to be driven nuts by the end.

Four stars. Worth a read, but definitely different.

Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher for review purposes.

[MurderByDeath]

I'm a fan of Lynn Truss' writing, though I haven't read all of it, and when this was announced it went on my wishlist because it's Lynn Truss *and* a mystery.     It was only after I'd finished reading it that I discovered it's a novelisation of something she'd written for BBC Radio 4, so there are those out there who may already be familiar with Constable Twitten, Sergeant Brunswick, and Inspector Steine.  These people might be better able to describe this book; the closest I was able to come for my husband was to say it's a little bit like 'Allo 'Allo, but not really.  For those not acquainted with British television, I have no parallel to offer.  Maybe Hogan's Heroes without Hogan and his heroes?   Set in Brighton in the 50's, this is a comedic mystery; it says so right on the tin.  Inspector Steine is basking in the reflected glory of the Middle Street Massacre of 1951, where the two criminal gangs of Brighton gathered one day for a showdown, and every single gang member killed in the subsequent shootout.  A shootout that only happened because Inspector Steine and his men stopped along the way to the scene for an ice cream.  Now, he believes there is no more crime in Brighton, and is deeply offended by Sergeant Brunswick's insistence that there is.  Constable Twitten in new on the scene and brings a level of precociousness and obnoxiousness to the station house that threatens to unravel Steine.   If there's a straight man in this trio, it's Sergeant Brunswick, but even he has his quirky weaknesses, including one for the variety shows and another for a 19 year old seductress who likes to play the criminal element against the law for kicks.   The mystery beings when a theatre critic from London arrives to view the preview showing of a new play called A Shilling in the Meter.  There's animosity between the playwright and the critic, but as the reader soon finds out there's animosity between the critic and pretty much everybody - even those that don't know him, due to an unfortunate body odour issue.  So it's no surprise to anybody except Twitten when the critic is shot and killed in the theater on opening night.  What happens from here is an intricately plotted, but convoluted mystery involving several deaths, both murderous and accidental.   The story is hilarious as only the British can really be, I think; it's a style of humor that won't work for everybody, especially those that don't care for an air of silliness, not even the staid, stiff-upper-lip kind.  I enjoyed it, though I didn't love it; there's a genius in Truss' plotting, and in her solution to several character problems.  The humor skirted the edges of whack-a-doodle at times, and the police are played for laughs, but Truss made it work for me.   I'm not sure who, if anyone, I'd recommend this book to.  It's bound to be one of those that people either enjoy or get fed up with.  I'll gladly read another if she writes it; I found the characters charming even when they were being dim, and the story made for a nice break from reality.