Leah
I WANTED TO LOVE COVER GIRL, BUT I DIDN'T
I'm quite the fan of Nic Tatano. He's such a talented writer and can write both Chick Lit and Young Adult, but Cover Girl didn't work for me. I'm not a fan of love triangles (or squares in the case of Lauren, Alex, Dash and Keira). It's hard to root for Alex and Keira when they're both playing the field. That's not the kind of romance I want, where they're dating others. Especially since I LOVED Lauren.
KEIRA WAS A WEAKER TATANO HEROINE THAN I'M USED TO
Keira was apparently this kick-ass editor, but we never saw that in her real life (or in her editing cave, to be fair). Gretchen was far more kick-ass, and even the lovely Lauren made more of an impression. In fact, I felt Lauren was wasted, she should have had her own novel. THE PLOT WAS INTERESTING, BUT FELL FLAT
I LOVE books about books, and I thought the plot sounded amazing, but it was sooooo wasted. I wanted to read more about a guy writing romance, I wanted to know what the reaction from the public would be (for what it's worth, I LOVE books written by ANYONE - as long as they're good, I couldn't care less what the gender is of the writer). The plot was more focused on the love square and I was so bored by it. OVERALL
Overall, I was disappointed. I expected so much more and it just wasn't as good as Tatano's other novels. I actually would have preferred to read Alex's version of Ring Girl, which sounded like a really sweet, under-complicated love story. You can never under-complicate a love story and I think the main problem with Cover Girl was it was too complicated.