What's a Witch to Do?: A Midnight Magic Mystery (Midnight Magic Mystery, #1)

by Jennifer Harlow

• ISBN10: 0738735140
• ISBN13: 9780738735146
• Publish Date: 8 March 2013
• Publish Status: Out of Print
• Out of Print: 7 August 2021
• Publish Country: US
• Imprint: Midnight Ink
• Format: Paperback
• Pages: 336
• Language: English

Reviews

[MurderByDeath]

Not a bad read. I think it started off a bit slow for me, although the pace picked up quickly enough. I tend to prefer that the characters I read about are strong, independent women with sass, and while Mona is all of those things, she's also sporting a massive inferiority complex and there's a lot of 'ugly duckling' throughout the story. It's tempered well with the strong aspects of her personality, but it did detract from my enjoyment of the story overall.

The mystery itself should have been an excellent one but for some reason it was completely predictable to me. I was convinced of the culprit VERY early in the book. But I will give Ms. Harlow kudo's for making me work so hard for vindication. :) She was able to convince me several times I must be wrong, only to re-convince myself I must be right. It was definitely a roller coaster ride, this plot line. Lots of action too, with the story peaking at several points, something that kept me totally involved in the plot.

The rest of the cast of characters are likeable or seem likeable for a first outing. The oldest niece (Sophie?) needs an attitude adjustment but given the past she's supposed to have come from, I suppose it's in keeping with the story. Adam is very likeable and I liked reading the interactions between him and Mona. There's more "romance" in this story than I expected. I expected sexual tension, sex, etc. But the actually 'I love you so much I'll set you free/you have to really want this' romance was unexpected, although not over the top.

I liked that this new series will be taking place in the same universe as the F.R.E.A.K.S. series and the crossover of a couple of characters was fun. I look forward to the next book in the series, and finding out where Ms. Harlow intends to take this series.

[Cocktails and Books]

ennifer Harlow has made me an official fangirl; she writes great female leads, there is tons of lust/love and there is always a good mystery. Mona is the quintessential take charge woman; she runs her family business, cares for two young nieces, is planning her sister’s wedding and is the local High Priestess. Where in that picture is there time for romance? Nowhere. And that’s when Adam Blue steps out of the shadows and into her life. Adam becomes Mona’s self-appointed protector when she is threatened.

Harlow does a great job of balancing the mystery of who is trying to kill Mona with the growing relationship between her and Adam. After a few chapters I became genuinely invested in whether Mona would push Adam out of her life or take a chance on love. Why? Because Harlow made these characters real. Who doesn’t identify with the woman who sacrifices everything for her family or community and thinks that she has missed her shot at finding her one true love? Harlow taps into that with Mona and makes you want to sit her down and say “This guy is for real, give him a chance.” The story is well told and Harlow builds enough tension to keep you reading and wanting more.

Reviewed by Karon for Cocktails and Books