Tulane Studies in Philosophy Series

Book 3

A Symposium on Kant

by Edward G Ballard, Richard L. Barber, James Kern Feibleman, Carl H. Hamburg, Harold N. Lee, Louise Nisbet Roberts, and Robert C. Whittemore

Published 31 January 1964

HE past does not change; it cannot, for what has happened T cannot be undone. Yet how are we to understand what has happened? Our perspective on it lies in the present, and is subject to continual change. These changes, made in the light of our new knowledge and new experience, call for fresh evaluations and constant reconsideration. It is now one hundred fifty years since the death of Immanuel Kant, and this, the third volume of Tulane Studies in Philosophy is dedicated to the commemoration of the event. The diversity of the contributions to the volume serve as one indication of Kant's persistent importance in philoso phy. His work marks one of the most enormous turns in the whole history of human thought, and there is still much to be done in estimating its achievement. His writings have not been easy to assimilate. The exposition is difficult and labored; it is replete with ambiguities, and even with what often appear to be contradictions. Such writings allow for great latitude in interpretation. Yet who would dare *to omit Kant from the account? The force of a man's work is measured by his influence on other thinkers; and here, Kant has few superiors. Of no man whose impact upon the history of ideas has been as great as that of Kant can it be said with finality: this 5 6 TULANE STUDIES IN PHILOSOPHY is his philosophy.

Book 4

Studies in American Philosophy

by Edward G Ballard, James Kern Feibleman, Richard L. Barber, Carl H. Hamburg, Harold N. Lee, Louise Nisbet Roberts, and Robert C. Whittemore

Published 31 January 1967

Book 7

The Nature of the Philosophical Enterprise

by Edward G Ballard, Richard L. Barber, James Kern Feibleman, Harold N. Lee, Paul Guerrant Morrison, Andrew J. Reck, Louise Nisbet Roberts, and Robert C. Whittemore

Published 31 January 1958

Book 8

Centennial Year Number

by James K Feibleman, Paul G. Morrison, Andrew J. Reck, Harold N. Lee, Edward G Ballard, Richard L. Barber, Carl H. Hamburg, and Robert C. Whittemore

Published 31 July 1959

The year 1959 has been called The Centennial Year in view of the anniversary of the publication of The Origin of SPecies and the centenary of the births of many who later contributed much to the philosophy of the recent past, such as Samuel Alexander, Henri Bergson, John Dewey and Edmund Husser!' The essays in the present volume which are on subjects germane to any of the anniversaries celebrated this year have been placed first in the present volume. CENTENNIAL YEAR NUMBER DARWIN AND SCIENTIFIC METHOD JAMES K. FEIBLEMAN The knowledge of methodology, which is acquired by means of formal education in the various disciplines, is usually com municated in abstract form. Harmony and counterpoint in musical composition, the axiomatic method of mathematics, the established laws in physics or in chemistry, the principles of mathematics - all these are taught abstractly. It is only when we come to the method of discovery in experimental science that we find abstract communication failing. The most recent as well as the greatest successes of the experimental sciences have been those scored in modern times, but we know as yet of no abstract way to teach the scientific method. The astonishing pedagogical fact is that this method has never been abstracted and set forth in a fashion which would permit of its easy acquisition. Here is an astonishing oversight indeed, for which the very difficulty of the topic may itself be responsible.

Book 9

Studies in Hegel

by Alan B. Brinkley, James K Feibleman, Mitchell Franklin, Paul G. Morrison, Andrew J. Reck, Robert C. Whittemore, and Edward G Ballard

Published 31 July 1969

Book 10

Studies in Whitehead’s Philosophy

by Edward G Ballard, Alan B. Brinkley, Ramona T. Cormier, Harold N. Lee, Stephen C Pepper, Andrew J. Reck, and Robert C. Whittemore

Published 31 January 1971

Book 11

Studies in Social Philosophy

by Edward G Ballard, James K Feibleman, Paul G. Morrison, Andrew J. Reck, and Robert C. Whittemore

Published 31 July 1962

Book 12

Studies in Recent Philosophy

by Andrew J. Reck, Harold N. Lee, Carl H. Hamburg, Louise Nisbet Roberts, James K Feibleman, and Edward G Ballard

Published 31 July 1963

Book 13

Studies in Philosophical Psychology

by James Kern Feibleman, Harold N. Lee, Donald S. Lee, Shannon Bose, Edward G Ballard, Robert C. Whittemore, and Andrew J. Reck

Published 31 July 1964

Book 14

The Problem of Truth

by Edward G Ballard, Shannon Dubose, James Kern Feibleman, Donald S. Lee, and Harold N. Lee

Published 31 July 1965

Book 16

Philosophical Logic

by Robert L. Arrington, Peter M. Burkholder, Shannon Dubose, James W. Dye, James K Feibleman, Bertrand P. Helm, Max Hocutt, Harold N. Lee, Louise N. Roberts, and John C. Sallis

Published 31 July 1968

With this issue we initiate the policy of expanding the scope of Tulane Studies in Philosophy to include, in addition to the work of members of the department, contributions from philosophers who have earned advanced degrees from Tulane and who are now teaching in other colleges and universities. The Editor THE LOGIC OF OUR LANGUAGE ROBERT L. ARRINGTON Wittgenstein wrote in the Tractatus that "logic is not a body of doctrine, but a mirror-image of the world. " 1 In line with his suggestion that a proposition is a 'picture', Wittgenstein argued that propositions 'show' the logical structure of the real. He was insistent, however, that "the apparent logical form of a proposition need not be its real one. " 2 As a result of this we can misunderstand the structure of fact. Philosophical problems arise just when "the logic of our language is mis understood. " 3 It is common knowledge that much of this view of logic was rejected by Wittgenstein himself in the Philosophical Investi gations. There we are told that language has no ideal or sublime 4 logic which mirrors the structure of the extra-linguistic world. Consequently, inferences from the structure of language to the structure of that extra-linguistic world are invalid. Reality can be 'cut up' in any of a number of ways by language. Wittgenstein adopted a view of philosophy which would render that discipline a non-explanatory, non-critical study of the multiple ways in which language can be used.

Book 17

Epistemology I

by Peter M. Burkholder, Shannon Dubose, James Wayne Dye, James K. Feiblemen, Max Hocutt, Donald S. Lee, Harold N. Lee, and Sandra B Rosenthal

Published 31 July 1968

Due to the unprecedented interest which the announcement of the topic of epistemology evoked from contributors, two annual volumes will be devoted to it. This volume accordingly is entitled Epistemology I, and the next volume will be entitled Epistemology II. The Editor KNOWING IN THE STRONG SENSE PETER M. BURKHOLDER Professor Norman Malcolm has defended what he calls "the strong sense" of "know." 1 It is one of the propositional senses; i.e. what is said to be known, in this sense, is an item of information rather than a person, a poem, a physical object, or a skill. According to· Malcolm, this sense of "know" is important and useful.' Philosophers have had it "in mind when they have spoken of 'perfect,' 'metaphysical,' or 'strict' cer tainty" (Ke, 70). Moreover, laymen use it when they profess to know such obvious truths as "2 + 2 = 4" or "This is an ink-bottle" (said while peering at and poking an ink-bottle). Nevertheless, in spite of his opinion that it is important, Malcolm has not given a detailed analysis of the strong sense of "know." Thus we may be justified in studying it, first to determine exactly what it is, and then to evaluate it. I do not, of course, wish to suggest that Malcolm necessarily WQuid accept my account of the strong sense as an accurate expli cation of his opinions. However, in its descriptive aspects my analysis seems compatible with his written statements.

Book 18