Reflective Democracy

by Robert E. Goodin

Published 13 February 2003
Democracy used to be seen as a relatively mechanical matter of merely adding up everyone's votes in free
and fair elections. That mechanistic model has many virtues, among them allowing democracy to 'track the
truth', where purely factual issues are all that is at stake. Political disputes invariably mix facts with
values, however, and then it is essential to listen to what people are saying rather than merely note how
they are voting. The great challenge is how to implement that deliberative ideal among millions of people at once. In this strikingly original book, Goodin offers a solution: 'democratic deliberation within'. Building on models of ordinary conversational dynamics, he suggests that people simply imagine themselves in the position of various
other people they have heard or read about and ask, 'What would they say about this proposal?' Informing
the democratic imaginary then becomes the key to making deliberations more reflective - more empathetic, more considered, more expansive across time and distance.